Rebane's Ruminations
January 2025
S M T W T F S
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031  

ARCHIVES


OUR LINKS


YubaNet
White House Blog
Watts Up With That?
The Union
Sierra Thread
RL “Bob” Crabb
Barry Pruett Blog

George Rebane

Over the holidays we watched a documentary on the life of Einstein in which his writings, interviews, and speeches were extensively quoted.  One of the social attributes that came out about the famed physicist was that he was a pacifist, more accurately an β€œactive pacifist”.  In his pacifism he publicly rejected imperialism, colonialism, racism, and gratuitous violence in general (e.g. brushfire wars, military actions to overthrow governments or capture territory, etc). 

However, he did not reject all wars and was adamant in maintaining that organized (evil) force can be successfully countered only by organized force.  He therefore believed in the good guys always being adequately armed to present a deterrence to the bad guys, but never attacking them first.  His most famous expression of this was the letter regarding the development of the atom bomb that he sent to FDR prior to the outbreak of WW2.  In this he strongly urged the US to start development of the bomb to counter Hitler’s efforts to do so (which turned out to be unsuccessful).

To shed more light on his attitude and role in promoting the advent of nuclear weapons and their use in Japan, he deeply regretted sending the letter after hearing of Hitler’s failure to develop the bomb.  He stated unequivocally that had he known that Germany was going to fail in their enterprise, he never would have communicated with FDR.  The documentary did not delve into his attitude about the millions of lives that the Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombs saved by eliminating the need to invade the Japanese home islands.

Having said all this, I had the mild epiphany that I too am and have been an Einsteinian pacifist all my life.  I suspect that many of you may also hold this belief.  It’s good to get such things clarified before it’s too late.

Posted in , , ,

12 responses to “Einsteinian Pacifism”

  1. Resurrected Hillbilly Avatar
    Resurrected Hillbilly

    I guess I would say I am an Einsteinian pacifist also.
    I take it the documentary did also not delve into his attitude regarding the Doolittle raid and Operation Meetinghouse which killed more Japanese than the nukes.

    Like

  2. George Rebane Avatar

    Hillbilly 1014am – You’re right, such massive terror bombing of civilians as in Tokyo and Dresden were not considered tradeoffs, only the horror of the single bomb’s carnage. Not sure why you referenced the Doolittle raid which militarily and casualty-wise was inconsequential.

    Like

  3. Resurrected Hillbilly Avatar
    Resurrected Hillbilly

    I only included it as it was mentioned in both the Brittanica and Wiki articles.
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombing_of_Tokyo
    https://www.britannica.com/event/Bombing-of-Tokyo

    Like

  4. Don Bessee Avatar
    Don Bessee

    Self-evident idiot who relies on wiki for info it is ignorant of. ROFLOL
    πŸ˜‰

    Like

  5. Gregory Avatar
    Gregory

    Einstein was a socialist… that he had a mind for physics doesn’t mean he understood government.

    Like

  6. George Rebane Avatar

    Gregory 507pm – And your point …?

    Like

  7. Gregory Avatar
    Gregory

    Selective pacifism leaning in the direction of Marcuse’ Repressive Tolerance isnt worth consideration.

    Like

  8. George Rebane Avatar

    Gregory 856pm – Wow! That has all the earmarks of another ex cathedra pronouncement. I trust you’ll still forgive those of us who very much find Einstein’s pacifism worthy of consideration.

    Like

  9. Gregory Avatar
    Gregory

    Wow indeed! This has all the earmarks of another planned denigration.
    In the last week I’ve done some reading about the International Rescue Committee after seeing their recent pleas for donation… Sir Patrick Stewart front and center. Here’s what they have to say about their founding:
    “Learn how the IRC was founded at the call of physicist, humanitarian — and refugee — Albert Einstein”
    https://www.rescue.org/article/albert-einstein-and-birth-international-rescue-committee
    I think Einstein is one of the all time greats, but his politics… not so much.

    Like

  10. George Rebane Avatar

    Gregory 1127am – a careful reading of my post reveals that I said nothing about embracing his politics, but only his definition of his own pacifism, which I find that I share. My politics are a more expansive and complex matter which these pages have sought to communicate for the last fifteen years.

    Like

  11. Gregory Avatar
    Gregory

    Got it, George. Pacifism without politics. A very brief treatment.

    Like

  12. Resurrected Hillbilly Avatar
    Resurrected Hillbilly

    Bessee@1223
    I am sorry you became incensed that I checked my facts and referenced sites that are not political in nature.

    Like

Leave a comment