Rebane's Ruminations
August 2013
S M T W T F S
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

ARCHIVES


OUR LINKS


YubaNet
White House Blog
Watts Up With That?
The Union
Sierra Thread
RL “Bob” Crabb
Barry Pruett Blog

Do not engage with him who has nothing to lose.  It is to fight at a disadvantage, for the other enters without encumbrance, because unaccoutred even of shame; and having auctioned off everything, he has nothing more to lose, and so may allow himself every insolence; ...  Gracian #172

George Rebane

As we continue our tailspin, here are a couple of milestones just passed (pardon the mixed metaphors).

The 13aug13 WSJ reports that “Federal judge Shira Scheindlin ruled on Monday that the New York City Police Department’s 'stop and frisk' policy violates the constitutional rights of minorities.”  The basis for her ruling was the now institutionalized and insane litmus test for detecting “racism”.  The judge and the plaintiffs simply pointed to “the large number of minorities stopped relative to their representation in the overall population”.   That was the sum and substance of what passes for liberal logic.   Never mind that blacks compose the overwhelming proportion of perps – e.g. almost 4 out 5 shooters – on the city streets (more here).  Mayor Bloomberg and most of the city’s residents are enraged at the prospect of the return of high crime rates, and we will track this case as it is appealed to higher jurisdictions.

(BTW, the graphic in ‘The Liberal Mind – Expendable Dead for More Votes’ illustrates the situation of population and perpetrator proportions.  Moreover, it suggests the utter innumeracy (insanity?) of allocating remedial resources according to wrong population proportions – here the fraction of blacks in NYC vs the fraction of black perps in NYC.)

Distinguished author – Bell Curve (with Herrenstein), Coming Apart: The State of White America 1960-2010 – and former liberal scholar Charles Murray points out in his latest – War on Poverty – that the national pathology being promoted by progressives is creating additional legions of dependent Americans through welfare programs like SNAP (food stamps).  He makes the strong case that such pathologies are now becoming mainstream, as in these cadres also morphing into dependable Democrat voters.  A compelling piece of evidence for this is that poverty rates kept decreasing after the Great Depression, and then started increasing after the launch of the War on Poverty in the mid-1960s.

“Liberal pension excesses are now jeopardizing liberal priorities.” reports the 12aug13 WSJ.  The only leftwingers still denying the ravages of union impressed pensions, both public and private, on the cities and states across the nation are the local know-nothing echo chambers and nationally prominent Democrats.  The latter no longer deny the fact, but remain conspicuously silent on the matter.  The cogent summary of all that is –

“Many people (including RR since 2007) have been predicting this crack-up for years, the inevitable result of a political alliance in which unions elect Democrats who pad benefits for unions, which then spend to re-elect Democrats, who repeat the cycle. The music stops only when the taxpayers are tapped out or the city and state can't borrow any more. Detroit had its reckoning last month, and Chicago may be headed the same way unless its liberal politicians decide that a crisis of their own creation is a terrible thing to waste.”

With the loss of the USS Enterprise (CVN-65) that was decommissioned this March, we are now down to ten nuclear super-carriers.  Recall that it is through these ten carrier task groups that the US projects force throughout the world and puts backbone into its (recently abandoned) diplomacy.  We note that it takes twice as many carriers to field a given number on active operations – the other half is being maintained and/or in training exercises.  It was not long ago that our force level was at twelve such carriers.  I note again that the power of the pen depends entirely on the sword that backs its scribbles.

Posted in , ,

76 responses to “Ruminations – 13aug13”

  1. Todd Juvinall Avatar

    BenE, so how would you make things better for a country like, say, Jamaica?

    Like

  2. Ben Emery Avatar
    Ben Emery

    The more important question Todd is how would you make Jamaica better? I think my positions are pretty clear but yours on the other hand are not other than let free market a.k.a. corporations take care of everything. What does that mean and look like in your vision?

    Like

  3. Gregory Avatar

    “Nobody gives away free stuff.”
    Obamaphones be free. Foodstamps are free stuff. Welfare is free stuff. Allowing someone to wait until they are ill before signing up for medical “insurance” is free stuff.
    “We all participate and we all benefit.”
    How does that differ to the following:”From each according to ability, to each according to need”?
    Regarding your examples, absolutely no one considers public education to be akin to welfare, and roads are substantially paid for by gasoline taxes, borne by all according to their use. No problems there; your arguments are off point and off the wall. The problem with public education isn’t access or funding but rather the inability of the monopolistic public schools as a whole to do a good job, or to take bad teachers out of the classroom.
    Regarding my interest in your education or lack of it, when running for congress against McC and the loony from Florida you claimed in your campaign literature to be a nursing student on hiatus for the campaign. Just checking.
    It does strike me your complaints about pay and paying for health care would have been moot had you spent some of the last 20 years to learn a trade that pays more than being a ranch hand for a relative.

    Like

  4. Todd Juvinall Avatar

    So let me get this straight BenE. I ask you how you would solve the problems you identify here as parmaiunt to you and you don’t answer but ask me how I would solve them.. OK, I get it. You have no solutions, only complaints.

    Like

  5. Scott Obermuller Avatar

    Wrong again, per usual Ben. I have witnessed how hard some folks work for a living and saying the only difference is infrastructure misses a huge point. I have never stated that hard work is the only thing standing in the way of prosperity in this country. The work done must result in something useful to others. The govt should not be the party to determine the usefulness because the govt is not providing the money. The more value, the higher the pay. Pushing a broom is low value and is low pay. Brain surgery tends to be of a much higher value to me and others, so a much higher pay. Some folks live in countries that have little or no natural resources that are of value to the rest of the world. They are never going to gain wealth unless they provide a service to others in the world that is found no where else. I have no obligation to provide money to any one that does not provide useful goods or service to me. And I have no right to take money from anyone unless I can provide something of service to them. Charity is a separate matter and should be provided voluntarily. I am happy to provide charity to those who truly need it.
    Infrastructure must be something that folks want. The so-called high speed rail is an excellent example of how socialized policies result in higher income inequality. I am forced to provide money to a scam that provides no service to me or millions of other folks. Who gets the money? Richard Blum (DiFi’s husband, what a coincidence) owns the company that won the bid to build the thing that I don’t want. So money is forcibly taken from the poorer person and handed to the wealthy person. No free market here.

    Like

  6. George Rebane Avatar

    BenE 1018am – Following up on a long unanswered point and one that builds on Scott’s 1115am, your refusal to acknowledge that free markets and corporatism are antithetical stops not only progress in the dialogue, but sheds little light for the reader on your tin ear here. Corporatism cannot exist without government bringing its power to bear to mangle the markets in favor of selected corporations. And only big governments with extensive enforcement apparatus (aka lots of guns) that funnel a large chunk of the GDP through their accounts can support corporatism. Left to lumber in a free market, these leviathans would be outflanked by the smaller and more nimble enterprises every time. But such a notion is invisible to progressives, or they are just too cynical to answer this with anything but crickets, and then continue to post comments that acknowledge no other truth than that first espoused in the 1848 Manifesto.

    Like

  7. fish Avatar
    fish

    They’re for single-payer, everybody in, nobody out, free choice of doctor and hospital. That’s been a majoritarian position for years. Living wage? Overwhelming. Anti-war? [About] 70% want us out of Afghanistan now. The Green Party stands for bringing the soldiers back and curtailing the American empire. Cutting the military budget? A majority of Americans think that the military’s budget is too big and should be cut. Getting rid of special tax breaks for corporations? Overwhelming support. Renegotiating NAFTA and WTO? Majority support. I can go on and on.
    Well good news for you then in your next election! That you are so in tune with the wishes of the electorate should make you a shoo in.

    Like

  8. Ben Emery Avatar
    Ben Emery

    Fish,
    I encourage you to read the entire article and if that peaks some interest the book Grand Illusion: The Myth of Voter Choice in a Two-Party Tyranny

    Like

  9. fish Avatar
    fish

    I encourage you to read the entire article and if that peaks some interest the book Grand Illusion: The Myth of Voter Choice in a Two-Party Tyranny
    Oh yeah Ben…I’m all over it! Your propaganda, My propaganda…what’s the diff?

    Like

  10. Scott Obermuller Avatar

    Voter choice is not a myth. You are, in fact, quite free to vote for anyone who qualifies for the job. You don’t have to drink Coke or Pepsi. There are millions of choices at the store and water right out of the hose, if you please. The left keeps howling about free choice and democracy for the masses. Then, those damn morons go off and vote all wrong. And they make the free choice to shop at WallyWorld, fer gawds’s sakes. Oh dear me – won’t the masses ever make the free democratic choices that Ben wants them to?
    Actually, Ben – we are going to end up with socialized health care in this country. Not sure why you lefties are so upset. Massive debt, massive wealth transfer. Millions sitting around doing nothing, just like those highly advanced socialized countries in Europe. What’s not to like?

    Like

  11. Bill Tozer Avatar
    Bill Tozer

    Mr. Ben. Funny thing about Jamaica. The slave traders made the mistake of nabbing slaves from a warrior tribe. Nothing non violent about that tribe. Its in their DNA. Anyways, those slaves overthrew the slave traders and commandeered the ship. Ended up happening in what we call modern day Jamaica. Those Jamaicans make great enforcers of the drug trade and put fear in those who skim a little off the top. Not to be messed with. Again, must be in their DNA.
    Jamaica is akin to Haiti and most of the countries in the entire 3rd world. Give every citizen 100 clams and by the end of the year 3% will have everybody’s 100 bucks in their hot little hands. That is what Sean Penn is finding out helping the quake victims in that region.
    Now, lets put aside this notion of the peace loving Muslim world once and for all. Can you name one Muslim country that is a functioning democracy? They just vote in dictators….er…followers of Sharia Law. Sharia law has no place ever for democracy. Just cause they have elections does not ever mean they have democracy. Name one Muslim controlled government anywhere on Plant Earth that extends equal right to women, Coptic Christians and homosexuals. Imagine a gay man or woman running for office in Syria. More like running for their lives! But, the again, there are no gay Muslims. If there were, they would be peace lobbing Muslims no doubt. At least Egypt’s population did some serious push back against the Brotherhood. “Brotherhood” my sorry rear end. Closer to kill them Coptic Christians and run every aspect of your lives through authoritarian’s iron fist. Worse than under Saddam or the previous Egyptian President we coaxed to flee.
    Remember that speech Obama gave in Cairo? One of the very first things he did as President. Even before he got the Nobel Peace and went off to Europe to wave his hand and make the Olympics come to Chicago? Anyway, the Egyptian President at the time said NO to the Brotherhood attending. No way, they are 100% Sharia law and death to gays and they treat women like cattle. It is a good thing, its the law, hahaha.
    Anyways, Obama insisted that the peace loving moderate Muslum Brotherhood attend the Cairo speech. Invited them over the President of the Egypt objections and refusal to let them attend. Yep, he laid down the vision in his Cairo speech alright. That vision was one big middle finger to the Egyptian Prez. Now we are left with no good options in Egypt…choice between bad and worse. Same with all those Ahad the Arab Spring nations. Never happen in Iran. Them Persians, not Ahabs the Arabs.
    Arab Spring my sorry rear end. It was and still is a fight for authoritarianism, aka complete power. Sharai law and all that jazz, not democracy. Let’s see now, name one Muslim Government that is worth a shit or democratic. In fact, name one country in Africa (besides South Africa and Rhodesia) that is worth a grunt sandwich. Congo? Algeria? Sudan? The beautiful Capital of Monrovia where rape is not a punishable offense? America is bad, first and foremost.

    Like

  12. Bill Tozer Avatar
    Bill Tozer

    Concerning the aircraft carrier and cuts to the military budget in general, I am thinking Ben is correct.
    This shocking news comes out of Britain. Not some wack job conspiracy theory, but genuine news involving Princess Di. Has nothing to do with speeds up to 85 miles an hour or alcohol, or a concrete pillar that was struck. No, even Scotland Yard is involved so we know it is the real McCoy. A British soldier killed Princess Di. Now, if Britain cut its military budget way back, Princess Die would still be around.
    http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2013/aug/17/princess-diana-death-police-information

    Like

  13. Bill Tozer Avatar
    Bill Tozer

    Concerning Stop and Frisk in NYC as being unconstitutional, oh well. Detroit was smart not to try that silly racist policy which puts people of color under the white man’s thumb. Detroit should know. Their murder rate is 11 times greater than that of the Big Apple.
    http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2013-07-21/25-facts-about-fall-detroit-will-leave-you-shaking-your-head

    Like

  14. George Rebane Avatar

    BillT 850pm – Thank you Mr Tozer for that Detroit data. It is these folks who for decades elected their own kind into city government. It reminds one of the Great Experiment about which our Founders admonished us.

    Like

  15. Bill Tozer Avatar
    Bill Tozer

    Mr. Rebane, something new under the sun about Detroit. With Detroit’s population at 83% African American, they may get away with it. No one will complaining about unfairly targeting people of color. It can’t hurt. Lord knows it might even help that crime ridden city.
    http://www.foxnews.com/us/2013/08/20/detroit-police-consider-stop-and-frisk-policy/?test=latestnews

    Like

  16. George Rebane Avatar

    BillT 749am – Mr Tozer, you correctly cite the population statistic for Detroit, but fail to recall that liberals are innumerate, especially those holding public offices. No matter the numbers, when more non-whites are involved in any pejorative way with crime, education, achievement, etc the mechanism for such attributions are ALWAYS racist. There simply is no other alternative.

    Like

  17. Todd Juvinall Avatar

    Watched Cspan this morning and it was a all black panel discussing all things unfair to people of color here in the USA. I shake my head in disbelief that these folks sitting up there drawing a salary of gazillions would be so ungrateful they live in this country of opportunity. But I got to hear their views of complaining about everything rather than any thankfulness. They spared no time in complaining about the “white man”. They represented the Congressional Black Caucus and other “non-profits” of the “progressive” bent.

    Like

  18. Bill Tozer Avatar
    Bill Tozer

    Dr. Rebane, it is a ugly stark fact you just uttered. Can’t agrue with that. I noticed the last paragraph in the article posted above:
    “Sybrina Fulton, the mother of Trayvon Martin, a black teenager who was shot to death by a neighborhood watch volunteer, said in an interview with NBC’s “Meet the Press” that “you can’t give people the authority, whether civilian or police officers, the right to just stop somebody because of the color of their skin.”
    So, Sybria Fulton is the new spokesperson and authority and reference to be quoted as a counter-argument to the story? Easy for her to say. She does not have to live in Detroit.
    One could even take her statement to mean you cannot stop someone who is darker skinned.

    Like

  19. Ben Emery Avatar
    Ben Emery

    Bill,
    Usually I can take our disagreements with chuckle but this Detroit rant is getting down right racist.
    What is it with you guys that makes it so you cannot comprehend the big picture very few issues?
    Median Net Worth Households in US
    Whites $113,000
    Hispanic $6,300
    Black $5,600
    This is where the history of being property not human for majority of our country comes into play. Those numbers represent much more than a monetary value. They represent nutrition, living environments, access to books and learning tools, after school activities, travel/ vacations, business or work connections, and so on. The lower the total the lower level of all those things mentioned are available to that family. Doesn’t mean they cannot get out of it but rather it is a much tougher road out of it. I grew up in lower half of middle class. Both my parents were dirt poor. My kids grew up pretty securely in the middle class. Here the thing about my parents. My dad grew up in rural CA and my mom in New York City. My mom was exposed to free museums, arts, international people, and a top notch education in the 40’s. She got a degree in English literature and became a teacher. My dad was sold on the old the way of doing things and thought he would work his way up the corporate ladder. After working with the same company for years he could no longer train anymore snot nose recent college grads that would pass him up for promotions. At 44 he started driving a truck independently.
    I guarantee a vast majority of those remaining who are not black in Detroit are poor. Go to Northern New England and you’ll find the same phenomena. People don’t leave because wages are so much lower and they cannot afford the move to a higher priced area. My brother lived between Maine/ Vermont/ New Hampshire for around 5 years. One year he made $6 an hour as as a laborer steel framer. The foreman of his crew who was making prevailing wage and had been with the company for over a decade was making $12 an hour. So not to many people moving from Caribou Maine down to Boston. My guess the same would go for Appalachia. Poverty is is a bitch to get out of especially if it has been generational poverty. George was lucky to benefit from the progressive era making college obtainable to all who qualified. We know for a fact that the GI Bill opened universities option for the first time in family histories. That investment along with all the other infrastructure investments from our government built the largest and strongest middle class in world history.
    My daughter is leaving this week to attend university in SF and our son is at St Mary’s in Moraga. The debt accumulated from sending them to higher education will challenge our mortgage in size. That is with tens of thousands of dollars in scholarships and grants. Universities and Banks are basically raping the American dream for every penny. Exiting higher education with huge debt loads with declining wages.
    I will end this rant by saying a country that doesn’t protect manufacturing and doesn’t primarily purchase goods made within their own borders is sending all their wealth out of the country.
    Power over a man’s subsistence is power over his will.
    Alexander Hamilton

    Like

  20. Ben Emery Avatar
    Ben Emery

    My guess you guys will either choose to or not understand the George remark in 20 August 2013 at 09:09 AM.
    George was an immigrant with no roots where he grew up. No family owns a piece of land or house that has been handed down generation to generation. So the ability to get up and move is much easier because those roots aren’t holding you down. That is why generational poverty is so hard to break.
    The mentality of; at least where we live now we have a place to live and can survive. If we move we will know nobody and will live a lower standard of living.

    Like

  21. Gregory Avatar

    ” Can you name one Muslim country that is a functioning democracy?” -Tozer
    Turkey

    Like

  22. Gregory Avatar

    Ben, generational poverty isn’t from having a crappy house in a crappy neighborhood and being tied to it, it’s from the secrets to staying poor and ignorant being handed down from parent to child, over and over.
    Are your kids studying something that will enable a career likely to pay off their educational debt? If not, start campaigning to revert the bankruptcy laws to allow the discharge of student loan debt in chapter 7 or 11 legal actions, they’ll need it.

    Like

  23. fish Avatar
    fish

    My daughter is leaving this week to attend university in SF and our son is at St Mary’s in Moraga. The debt accumulated from sending them to higher education will challenge our mortgage in size. That is with tens of thousands of dollars in scholarships and grants. Universities and Banks are basically raping the American dream for every penny. Exiting higher education with huge debt loads with declining wages.
    And yet you let them do this knowing it’s a poor course of action?
    Universities and Banks are basically raping the American dream for every penny.
    What?? Two years at a community college is beneath an Emery? Cognitive dissonance really is a hereditary trait.

    Like

  24. Bill Tozer Avatar
    Bill Tozer

    Brother Bee, my sista from another Mista: There are poor neighborhoods all across the fruited plain, including the poorest of the poor in rural Kentucky and West Virginnie. What makes Detroit so special is that it is a modern day tragedy. 5 times the national violent crime rate, 11 times the murder rate of NYC. 60% of all children residing in Motor City living below the national poverty rate. 47% of all folks over 16 are functionally illiterate.. Ben, we ain’t talking about growing up in a low income family or hood. No sirree. We are talking about growing up in a city where there are 78,000 abandoned/vacant home, where 2/3 of the public parks are closed up and the police stations are closed to the public 16 hours a day.
    What we are talking about is more like Lord of the Flies, not Watts. So, if I support Stop and Frisk in Detroit as a possible small solution to the crime problem, you think that is racist? Would you have your beloved children or wife spend 2 weeks in one of Detroit’s houses that are selling for 500 bucks? My point it is easy for Sybria F to gab about Stop n Frisk speaking from sunny Florida in relatively safe neighborhoods. She probably never had to walk uphill through the snow to school, both ways. My point is Sybria and you are comparing apples to oranges.
    Since when is talking about crime racist? Or black on black crime? Opps, I forgot. Talking about crime in a city that is 83% African American and the city government is 100% Africian American and the Police Chief is African American is ALWAYS racist speak. Me bad. What is Sybrina’s solution to the crime rate??? Less Stop and FrisK or no Stop and Frisk? What is your solution? Detroit has 100,000 creditors they owe money to, 47% of the budget goes to salaries and health care obligations, and they have 20 billion in unfunded liabilities.
    Detroit might turn things around. They have appointed another Emergency Education Czar to go along with their Emergency Fiance Czar that took over the city’s checkbook.
    I know the solution. Have somebody donate enough money to fix the 40% of the street lights that don’t work in Detroit. Green bulbs to boot. That will end crime, lower the drop out rate and makeup to 55% of the adult population functionally literate. Maybe even 56%.
    Detroit’s problems are first because of racism, then George W did his evil deeds, and now because of Big Corporations robbed the residents of the few pennies they have left. Dr. Rebame is 100% correct. Waste of time trying to counter that 2+2=3. Its Lord of the Flies, Brother Ben, nothing less.
    I am a racist bigot prejudice homophobic shrill of corporate Amerika. I don’t believe in the Californication of America either. I am a lost cause. Got to go. Just bought me a new Hudson Sprayer and I better go squirt down the homeless before they get warm. They use awful profanity when I give them their morning bath. But, I always forgive them. Not because what they say to be, but rather that is the kind of guy I am living on this altruistic plane.

    Like

  25. Bill Tozer Avatar
    Bill Tozer

    Breaks my heart every time:
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zwGTlpBHs7Y

    Like

Leave a comment