George Rebane
Well boys and girls, the candidates went after each other in a most civil manner tonight. The ad hominems were at an absolute minimum. Hillary's health was not an issue; the lady stood up to the rigors of the evening in a commendable manner. Both gave presidential level performances, and if anything, I would have to give Hillary a slight edge in her demeanor and how her messages impacted the undecideds. If I divide 100 points, Hillary would get 53 and Trump 47. More to say about the whole affair, but it's late and time for readers to weigh in.
[28sep16 update] The most cogent analysis of the debate's national impact on our body politic comes from Newt Gingrich who writes 'The Intellectual Yet Idiot Class Gets the Debate Wrong (Again!)'. From his report I extract some of the remarkable scores of the debate that have been generated and collected by various publications. (H/T to reader)
Time: Trump 55 Clinton 45
Fortune: Trump 53, Clinton 47
N.J.com (New Jersey): Trump 57.5, Clinton 37.78
CNBC: Trump 68, Clinton 32
WCPO Cincinnati: Trump 57, Clinton 37
Variety: Trump 58.12, Clinton 41.88
Slate: Trump 55.18, Clinton 44.82
WKRN Nashville: Trump 64.58, Clinton 35.42
Las Vegas Sun: Trump 82, Clinton 18
Fox5 San Diego: Trump 61.45, Clinton 33.69
San Diego Tribune: Trump 65, Clinton 35


Leave a comment