Rebane's Ruminations
August 2025
S M T W T F S
 12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930
31  

ARCHIVES


OUR LINKS


YubaNet
White House Blog
Watts Up With That?
The Union
Sierra Thread
RL “Bob” Crabb
Barry Pruett Blog

[This is the first of which I hope will be several reports from Barry Pruett in Russia.  Barry is a friend and a longtime reader of RR.  We all wish him safe travels in a very harsh part of the world.  gjr]

Barry Pruett

Well, it seems that Trump and Putin are going to meet and then after that they will both meet with Zelenskyy. It is interesting that Europe is being left out – a fact that has been pointed out extensively here. I do not think that the Russians have a huge problem with America right now, as they seem to be more disgusted with western Europe (Merz, Macron, Stamer). My prayer is that they can find a way to end the war, because there are a lot of people dying for no reason. I also hope that they meet and achieve peace while we are here. That would make the trip even more special than it already has been.

What is happening on the front in Ukraine is highly relevant to these negotiations. Russia is lava-rolling Ukraine in western Ukraine. It is not a question, but a simple and undeniable fact. Russia has Pokrovsk and Myrnograd (major logistical hubs for the war in Donbass) basically surrounded. Russians dropped leaflets to the Ukrainians holding out in Pokrovsk warning them to surrender before Russia closes the loop. Russia has acquired 100% of Lugansk, the bulk of Donetsk, and more than half of Kherson and Zaporozhia. Russia believes that it is more important to achieve its military objects than have a rapprochement with the USA.

As such, Russia has three main objectives. Istanbul Plus so to speak, similar to the agreement that Ukraine and Russia had in March of 2022 which was torpedoed by the West. First, Russia is taking the four above-referenced territories by force or by agreement. Second, Ukraine will never enter NATO. Third, Ukraine's military must be substantially reduced. It appears that these three items are existential for Russia, so until they are agreed or forced, the war will continue. Indeed, and in addition to NATO enlargement to Ukraine and Georgia (Black Sea access) which is a much more in-depth conversation, much of the problem stemmed from the western half of Ukraine being predominantly ethnic Russians.

Prior to the war, these ethnic Russians were previously being persecuted by the Ukrainian government dominated by western (NATO) interests. Such persecution included but is not limited to restrictions on Russian language in schools and restrictions on Orthodox churches. Indeed, the in-law of a friend of mine had a church in Ukraine near Kharkov in 2022 when the war started. His family fled to Voronezh. He stayed with his church. Shortly after his family fled, the Ukrainians burned down his church and my friend's in-law disappeared. It is unknown whether they killed him or whether he was conscripted and sent to the front. In any event, his family has not heard from him in over three years.

Also, as Ukraine runs short on manpower, they are intensifying conscriptions and sending unwilling participants to the front. I saw a video yesterday of a man who was in the process of being detained for conscription. He looked to be in his mid-50s. He pulled the pin on a grenade that he was holding and told the conscriptors that if he goes, they go. My understating is that he was eventually detained.

Ukraine also passed a law men over 60 to enlist. Indeed, they are running out of bodies to put into the grinder and things are desperate. No doubt, these events are what is, in part, driving Trump's urgency. NATO is going to lose Biden's war, and there is nothing NATO can do about it. Of course, Putin and Trump want an offramp, but like in any mediation, they have been too far apart to get an agreement. With the front changing and the lava-rolling continuing, reality may be setting in for Ukraine and the West that it is only a matter of time and consequently the parties are getting closer to where this thing is going to end.

That's it for today. I have to get back to work! I would be glad to talk to you in more detail in a Zoom conference (if Zoom works) or by some other video method. We leave here in October and with then be in eastern Europe until Christmas. See you then hopefully.

[Later]  Also, while you slept, Kirill Dmitiriev (Witkoff’s counterpart) announced that the meeting between Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin next week has the potential to be “historic.”. The location has been chosen, but has not been released yet. That’s not really like that Russian hype stuff up like Trump does. They must’ve made a deal already.

Posted in ,

12 responses to “Report from Moscow”

  1. scenes Avatar
    scenes

    Interesting. Keep ’em comin’.
    From my comfy chair, my basic theory on these matters is that:
    a) Ukraine citizens want to be a member of the EU so that they can all move there. Before all this started, it appeared to be just Russia Lite.
    b) I could draw the endgame map with a magic marker on paper and not be too wrong. All the deaths and resources expended are rather useless.
    c) Dunno why a chunk of the US populace built a religion out of anti-Israel, pro-unlimited 3rd world immigration, pro-Ukraine, pro-men in dresses, pro-‘vaccine’, anti-West…with a core group of older white wimmen. It’s such an unpredictable and peculiar thing that it just proves my lack of understanding of human nature.
    d) Drones are going to make the Land-Air battlefield evolve from WWI slugfests to some new thing I can’t guess. The interesting moves will be in countermeasures. In the meantime, the US appears to be dumping a lot of lucre into old-school big leagues weapons systems.

    Like

  2. Resurrected Hillbilly Avatar
    Resurrected Hillbilly

    Barry P. – are you getting your information from Russians that live in country?
    Word on the street is that they are horribly misinformed because of Rooskie Propaganda News.
    They are probably monitoring this thread – so tread lightly, or you could end up with some contraband in your luggage and a long term residency.
    The new Trump Road to link Armenia with a satellite region and agreement to drill baby drill, mine, or whatever (more Trump Hotels?) on Trump Highway might trigger Vlad.
    We will see how the Alaska summit progresses.
    Where is Zelenskey in all this? Not invited to the party?
    Check your facts, Putin started the war – not Biden (Typical MAGA propaganda)

    Like

  3. Resurrected Hillbilly Avatar
    Resurrected Hillbilly

    corr. – link Azerbaijan with its enclave.

    Like

  4. Thomas O'Toole Avatar
    Thomas O’Toole

    Berry, appreciate and thank you for such an informative and important chronicle.
    You are now a part of this regions history…
    Eagerly awaiting further updates.
    Also, Thank you Dr. Rebane.

    Like

  5. Rauber Avatar
    Rauber

    Who is Barry Pruett? He is unreflectingly repeating the Russian Narrative in their media which can only repeat what the regime allows otherwise the journalists etc. would end in prison. If Pruett himself believes what he is writing from Moscow he seems to me as a very simple thinking person who is far away from reality. What is the purpose of his travelling to Russia? It would be interesting to know. Maybe he is an “evangelikaler Missionar”. That would explain some. Christel Rauber

    Like

  6. Barry Pruett Avatar
    Barry Pruett

    I am writing my dissertation on the 1993 Russian Constitutional Crisis and Clinton’s rhetoric related thereto. I am here doing research here at the Lenin Library until October 16. The Russian people are very happy that peace is possible and they like Trump for making it happen. They are also happy to point out that Alaska was sold to the USA by Alexander II in the 1860s. I think the larger point about the choice of Alaska for the summit has to do with the fact that the United States and Russia do have a shared history and that they are both Arctic nations. We are indeed neighbors.
    It takes two to fight. Looking at the current situation in Ukraine as good versus bad or black and white is naive. Ukraine has been a red line for Russia is since the early 90s. I lived here from 1993 through 1994. I lived through the Russian constitutional crisis and indeed I watched it live with my own eyes. I was under the bridge where the tanks were when they shot at the White House. 1993 Russia and the consequences of choices made in the United States is the subject of a doctoral thesis. If you think that I am ill informed, I could give you a list of books that I invite you to read so you can catch up. The list would be very long however.

    Like

  7. Barry Pruett Avatar
    Barry Pruett

    Dammit. Now I missed my Metro Station. Lol

    Like

  8. Rauber Avatar
    Rauber

    Answerto Barry Pruett: Russian people could have been happy without that terrible war, if Putin wouldn’t have started to attack the Ukraine. I wonder which University sent you to Moscow to write this dissertation and who are the Professors who act as your doctor fathers? Russian people are held dumb and stupid. The most intelligent ones left already. Your view right now is naive and the tendence is to strenghthen Putin’s narrative. Christel Rauber

    Like

  9. Barry Pruett Avatar
    Barry Pruett

    See my post to George Rebane in his comparison to pre-WWII Europe.
    No university “sent” me to Moscow; I came here because I needed to be here for my research. My dissertation has no doctoral “father;” that is not how this process works. I asked scholarly questions which are as yet unanswered and found primary source records and scholarly research to answer my questions. I drew conclusions based upon these primary sources and scholarly research related thereto. I have no time for narrow minded people who conclude without evidence in order to confirm their own biases rather than to seek understanding.
    https://www.sierrathread.com/thread/moscow-today-is-still-a-very-nice-place-despite-sanctions
    You should love this video. Lol. This will be our last conversation, Ms. Rauber. It has been quite the pleasure.

    Like

  10. fish Avatar
    fish

    The beauty of war in the East. Everybody started it and everybody is suffering the most.
    Can’t the United States stop throwing money into this Eastern European mudhole, quietly depart now, and let nature take its course?

    Henry Kissinger — ‘It may be dangerous to be America’s enemy, but to be America’s friend is fatal.’

    ….apocryphal?

    Like

  11. Barry Pruett Avatar
    Barry Pruett

    Scenes at 1249p – First I misspoke in my post when I said western Ukraine above, I meant eastern Ukraine.
    Ukraine is not an homogenous area. Eastern Ukraine is primarily Russian the further east you go from the Dnieper. While western Ukrainians may have wanted to be part of the West, Russians in eastern Ukraine do not. This is evident from national election results for the past 20 years in Ukraine. Indeed in Samuel Huntington’s article “Clash of Civilizations”, he drew a line between the West and the East as follows: east of the Baltics and west of Russia, continuing south between Poland and Belarus, and then right through the middle of Ukraine. That was in 1991. So yep, the line that you would have drawn has scholarly support and is based upon cultural differences. Culture matters.
    Drone warfare?! Brutal and unimaginable. The videos online are astonishingly devastating. There is nowhere to run and nowhere to hide. It is not WWI or WWII. It is something very, very different.

    Like

  12. Resurrected Hillbilly Avatar
    Resurrected Hillbilly

    Barry Pruett | 11 August 2025 at 12:08 AM
    Next stop Kiev? Let’s see what kind of shape that city is in. What was that armed man in the background guarding? Was that a machine gun?
    If the Russia that Putin lets you see looks fine, then why do you suppose TACO Trump is afraid to ramp up the sanctions?

    Like

Leave a comment