Rebane's Ruminations
April 2018
S M T W T F S
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930  

ARCHIVES


OUR LINKS


YubaNet
White House Blog
Watts Up With That?
The Union
Sierra Thread
RL “Bob” Crabb
Barry Pruett Blog

Socialism is a philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance, and gospel of envy; its inherent virtue is the equal sharing of misery.  Winston Churchill

George Rebane

George Boardman, our favorite left-leaning columnist and reader, writes a solid piece (here) in the 30apr18 Union on the effects of taxation on pot in California and our county.  He even brings up the Laffer Curve (gasp!) to illustrate how higher tax rates lower govt revenues and give rise to black markets.  As memorialized by countless citations, comments, and even vituperation in these pages, a sacrosanct tenet of progressive economic theory is that tax rates affect neither production nor consumption.  Do we have here an epiphany in the making?

The Left is now all agog about how we can and should regulate AI – in its development and uses.  The 30apr18 WSJ interviews three “AI experts” on the matter (here) who are really policy lawyers and demonstrate little understanding of AI as they counsel little to a lot of needed regulations.  No one considers that we really need no additional regulation of productized AI because they are at best decision support systems always operating under a responsible human agent for whom all existing laws apply.  It is the human who has the power to employ AI as a tool, and then be responsible for its employment under existing laws.  Things can change later when the AIs become sentient and then sapient.  (See also the post of my recent Union column on this topic.)

California’s progressive socialism has produced the state with the largest income inequality in the Union, and it’s on the rise as more and more middle-class wage earners are pulling up stakes and moving elsewhere.  Joel Kotkin assembles some of this alarming data (H/T to reader) to give perspective to the Left’s claim that California is the model for tomorrow’s America.  “Today, domestic net out-migration, even after declining in the early years of the recession, has more than doubled between 2013 and 2016. Even worse, according to a recent UC Berkeley study, over a quarter of Californians are considering a move, half of them out of the state, with the strongest proclivity found among people under the age of 50. And contrary to some progressive commentary, those leaving are not necessarily old or losers; according to IRS data, out-migrant households had a higher average income than those households that stayed, or of households that moved in to the state.” (more here)

What level of neurological deficits must a person have to still believe that Mueller's year-plus investigation has turned up the slightest evidence of Trump/Russia collusion that, if it exists, would have been leaked months ago?  Why would that lot of liberal lawyers allow their fellow Dems to look like idiots as they repeatedly squawk evidence-free allegations on the media as 'proof' of Trump's guilt? (more here)

[1may18 update]  The Mueller gauge is still on EMPTY, as the latest spate of leaks confirms.  The list of ‘questions for Trump’ first leaked to the NYT, is an embarrassing fishing expedition that seeks nothing beyond the President’s recollections of his own thoughts about this and that, guesses at what other people might have been thinking, opinions about their pre-campaign activities, notions of the meanings of this or that concept or legal construct, … .  In short, the man has found no definitive actions or occurrences involving the Trump campaign that would support the now tidal wave of lamestream allegations serving as desperate proxies for no evidence of a conspiracy with Russia to influence the 2016 election.  When this is pointed out, all the leftwing choir is able to retort can be set to Lerner and Loewe’s ‘Just you wait ‘Enry ‘Iggins’, just you wait!’

California’s school kids have been had by the unionized public school teachers and leftwing politicians, as noted here for years.  The progressives who have created this disaster refuse to even acknowledge it, guaranteeing that the future will be no better, and probably worse, than the past.  Today 65% of our 8th graders are NOT PROFICIENT in reading, and 67% of them are NOT PROFICIENT in math.  This places CA 36th nationwide in reading and math, and that itself is another disaster story – with stats like that, how did we place so high, and still have 14 states scoring lower.  Oi weh!  (H/T to reader and more here)

Posted in , , ,

88 responses to “Ruminations – 30apr18 (updated 1may18)”

  1. rl crabb Avatar

    I just had someone on Facebook tell me the Silicon Valley techies are ready to sacrifice their bloated incomes to give everyone in California a guaranteed income. I can’t wait, and I can’t hold my breath that long.

    Like

  2. George Boardman Avatar

    Epiphany? That will occur when conservatives start practicing what they preach.
    Saint Authur is invoked when conservatives are criticizing liberal tax and spend policies. When conservatives actually get the opportunity to put the Laffer Curve to work, they either try to starve the beast (Kansas is one example) or blow big holes in the national debt (Trump tax cuts).

    Like

  3. Gregory Avatar
    Gregory

    Crabby, the “techies” won’t sacrifice their “bloated incomes” until property owners sell their old homes for a reasonable appreciation from prices in 1980. That might be soon now that unlimited SALT (state and local tax) IRS deductions are off the table.
    No, there will be riches beyond the Dreams of Avarice until the old rules for the markets apply… no money for nothing and the chicks for free. Got to have real stuff selling for a large margin over the cost to produce, not expecting people to open their lives for sale to the highest bidder to play a game.
    As long as it takes two incomes above 200k to purchase a starter home, they won’t be sacrificing much.
    Boardman… you don’t seem to grok what the Laffer curve is… it isn’t about balancing the budget which, if you believe Uncle Milty (Friedman) doesn’t really do much. It’s spending that needs to be curbed to reality as currency markets will bring wealth flows into balance if money is created to be wasted. Ommmm. Laffer curve is a relation between tax receipts and tax rates… and only between those two things.
    Laffer does not claim authorship of the so-called Laffer curve, crediting a 14th century Arab philosopher with noticing small tax rates bringing in large revenues at the beginning of one dynasty, and by the end of the dynasty, higher rates bringing in not so much…
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muqaddimah#Laffer_Curve

    Like

  4. Todd Juvinall Avatar
    Todd Juvinall

    George Boardman | 30 April 2018 at 01:58 PM
    What is it that liberals are about “anything” goes and have wrecked the country and the conservatives try to repair it and all we get is crapola from old farts like Boardman?
    I watched the liberals Boardman is so enamored with at that DC dinner last night. What a bunch of mean nasty worthless people. All heroes to GeorgeB. Sad.
    Spending is out of control in America and it certainly will lead to the nations demise if not brought under control. However, it is a liberal/democrat ideology that has made this happen. Look at California and you will see the paradise the left wants. Rich tech liberals and poor gardeners for their mansions. That sums it up.

    Like

  5. jon smith Avatar
    jon smith

    Todd 3:16
    “Spending is out of control in America and it certainly will lead to the nations demise if not brought under control.”
    Yep. Those damn libs and their out of control spending. And who owns the presidency? aWho owns congress? Who owned the senate? Who proposed the budget? Who passed the budget? Who blew open the debt ceiling? Oh yes, those libs. Squeak: Crooked Hillary did it!

    Like

  6. Russ Avatar
    Russ

    Jon @03:36 PM
    You are right the budget got busted. The budget-busting became necessary when the Democrats in the Senate demanded their social programs are funded, or they would not vote for the budget, ending in more Gov Shut down.
    GOP leaders pitched a deal that would boost domestic agencies’ budgets by $45 billion to $50 billion for the next two years. Democrats, however, insisted on at least $60 billion in additional domestic spending. That is $60 Billion the Republican did not plan to spend; it was used to buy Democrat Senate votes, including the funding of a tunnel under the bay from NJ to NY. The budget would have been a lot slimmer of the Republican’s did not have to buy Democrat votes. So, who were the budget busters? Oh?

    Like

  7. scenes Avatar
    scenes

    “And who owns the presidency? Who owns congress? ”
    In terms of the budget? I’d say that it’s the recipients of SS and Medicare.
    The military budget, in terms of a percentage of GDP, has been dropping since the Korean War. There’s not a lot lot of wiggle room after those three things are added up, plus interest on the debt has to be added in.
    Without a big hit on SS/Medicare at some point (means testing?) we’ll probably just inflate our way out of it. You probably should buy a wheelbarrow for bank deposits.

    Like

  8. Walt Avatar

    The LIBS may have 100% of the graveyard yard vote well secured,
    but not so much for the young and breathing.
    http://www.breitbart.com/california/2018/04/30/california-voter-pre-registration-of-100000-teens-only-38-democrats/
    Just maybe,, thanks to the Internet, the young are wising up and not buying the Socialist “we will take care of you” BS.
    Or maybe the state trying to suck away a good portion of their income in the name of healthcare is causing the backlash.

    Like

  9. George Rebane Avatar

    GeorgeB 158pm – Mr Boardman, you are criticizing the Repubs for working the Laffer curve. Both Kansas and Trump’s tax cuts are works in progress. And there is no guarantee that the tax cuts will not work as you per your fait accompli. Oh yes, did you forget to mention Obama’s doubling the national debt with no measurable benefit to recession recovery save making it the slowest in America’s history?

    Like

  10. jon smith Avatar
    jon smith

    Russ 4:02
    “GOP leaders pitched a deal that would boost domestic agencies’ budgets by $45 billion to $50 billion for the next two years.”
    So I guess when they couldn’t pitch their deal, Republicans “settled” on an additional $80 billion for the Pentagon this year and another $85 billion in 2019. Those tricky libs fooled the Republicans into jacking up over $165 billion in defense spending alone over two years.

    Like

  11. Todd Juvinall Avatar
    Todd Juvinall

    Unfortunately the Senate won’t change the filibuster rule and they extorted the R’s and got their pork. Trump was more concerned about the military so he begrudgingly signed stating “never again”. Anyway, the left is the responsible party along with Obama in the huge debt.

    Like

  12. Don Bessee Avatar
    Don Bessee

    Another example the ‘jon’ can not count too high, in this instance he was unable to count to 60. 😉

    Like

  13. jon smith Avatar
    jon smith

    Todd 4:56
    Those libs and their filibusters! Was it the libs who enacted more filibusters during the Obama administration than the TOTAL of all other filibusters in history, or was it the tooth fairy? Somewhere it is written (Maybe the Federal Register or some other fake news source) that 72% of all filibusters have been initiated by Repubs.
    Squeals from the right Hillary invented the filibuster, just to mess with Trump

    Like

  14. Scott Obermuller Avatar

    “That will occur when conservatives start practicing what they preach.”
    Are you assuming all Rs are conservatives? Hardly. Careful what you complain about, Boardman.
    If the solons in DC were actual conservatives, they would balance the budget and you’d be the first to start screaming. Most Rs in DC are not conservatives. I don’t care what they say they are.
    SS and Medicare are budget busters. They were set up that way decades ago and God help anyone in DC who even hints that something might have to be done about it. Pretty soon you won’t have to worry about the defense budget. There won’t be one. Debt service and entitlements will swallow the entire budget and we’ll still be drowning in red ink.
    The numbers are plain. It isn’t a matter of opinion.

    Like

  15. Don Bessee Avatar
    Don Bessee

    We shall see….
    n the last few weeks, Mayor Mark Farrell has promised $750,000 to hire more people just to pick up discarded needles and $13 million over the next two years for more heavy duty steam cleaners and pit stop toilets. He also had workers dismantle sprawling homeless tent camps in the city’s Mission District.
    The city famed for its picture-perfect views of the San Francisco Bay has long tolerated overflowing trash bins and homeless people camped out on sidewalks. Commuters routinely walk past people slumped over in transit stations, sometimes shooting up in public.
    But Farrell and others say the squalor has gotten out of control, and that everyone should feel safe using city sidewalks. It is not humane to let the mentally ill or houseless fester outdoors, he said.
    “The trash, our homeless, the needles, the drug abuse on our streets, I’ve seen it all in our city and it’s gotten to the point where we need to really change course,” Farrell said in an interview. “We’ve gone away from just being compassionate to enabling street behavior and that, in my opinion, is a shift that’s unacceptable.”
    What does this part of the article say about NYC?
    New York City resident John Rajnic, who was waiting to ride a cable car, said the city looks dirtier than when he was here nearly a decade ago, but he says the reaction is overblown.
    https://www.yahoo.com/news/tolerant-san-francisco-fed-dirty-smelly-streets-193935341.html
    😉

    Like

  16. jon smith Avatar
    jon smith

    Bessee 5:09-
    “Another example the ‘jon’ can not count too high, in this instance he was unable to count to 60.”
    Huh? Keep talking into your hat Don, you might become a Mormon.

    Like

  17. Todd Juvinall Avatar
    Todd Juvinall

    Oh jonnie, Hillary got how many R’s for her confirmation? The voe for hwer was 94-2! And your pals of the extreme left can’t vote but seven for Pompeo? You are a uber partisan and it shows with every post. And most of the time you hae your facts wrong. So unless you can back up your yapping I suggest you take another hit on your bong and sleep it off.

    Like

  18. jon smith Avatar
    jon smith

    Todd 6:17
    “The voe for hwer was 94-2!”
    Translation: “My whore in the sewer . . .” Oh, I give up. So what did you and your whore do in the sewer?

    Like

  19. Don Bessee Avatar
    Don Bessee

    Somebody flush the ‘jon’ its overflowing again. To remind our lefties about the realities of a majority versus control in the senate, 51 don’t get it boys the game is 60. So save all your BS about total control.
    😉

    Like

  20. jon smith Avatar
    jon smith

    Bessee 6:41-
    “51 don’t get it boys the game is 60.”
    The same razor beard Okie who crumples to the sidewalk and cries while lamenting about California’s super majority asks why his side is allowed to lose a vote. it isn’t fair If Mitch, Ryan, and Donny together can’t pull out the votes that they “deserve”, then maybe you should take a step back and reconsider the concept of checks and balances. But you would rather cry and spend another 40 minutes trimming the hair off your face. And all this time you and Walt said you were winning and not whining.

    Like

  21. Don Bessee Avatar
    Don Bessee

    Well that sure hit the parliamentarians soft spot @ 654!

    Ya cant vote legally but you can vote on the fate of citizens, really?
    Immigrants residing in California illegally would be able to serve on all state and local boards and commissions under a proposal introduced in the state Senate on Monday.
    Senate Bill 174 amends existing state law to allow the appointment of any resident over the age of 18 to a civil office regardless of citizenship or immigration status. California law currently states that someone is incapable of holding office if they are not a citizen at the time of their appointment.
    http://www.sacbee.com/news/politics-government/capitol-alert/article210184089.html
    😉

    Like

  22. Paul Emery Avatar

    George
    You optimism that Trump is going to skate free is a bit premature. What do you know about what information Mueller already has obtained from Flynn and others that have already plea bargained a good deal with their guilty to a lesser charge ploy from Mueller. Also just tonight the NYT has published a story about the questions he would like to ask Trump if he would submit to questions. The NYT explains that these were provided by the Trumps ex legal team who summarized the questions based on verbal questions that Muellers team offered to Trumps lawyer John Dowd shortly before he quit representing Trump in the matter. Here’s the NYT list of questions. Take a look and let me know what you think.
    https://www.nytimes.com/2018/04/30/us/politics/questions-mueller-wants-to-ask-trump-russia.html

    Like

  23. Don Bessee Avatar
    Don Bessee

    Talkin about this guy ya po’ ol’ fakenewsman?
    He ‘Destroys People’: Gohmert Demands Mueller Resign in Report on Bureaucrat’s ‘Problematic’ Past
    http://insider.foxnews.com/2018/04/30/robert-mueller-should-resign-louie-gohmert-says-new-report-russia-probe
    😉

    Like

  24. Todd Juvinall Avatar
    Todd Juvinall

    Vote for her was 94-2. My spelling sucks. Anyway you of course don’t debate the point you would rather spell check. The R’s are not as partisan as the D’s, your ilk. Hillary was as crooked as they come, your favorite way of a democrat, and yet she got all the R’s except 2 to vote for her. It is the democrat lefty extremists that are wrecking America. We will deal with you soon.

    Like

  25. Paul Emery Avatar

    Don
    No chance some obscure Texas Congressman is going to force Mueller to resign. He has too many Republican supporters and is a Republican himself.

    Like

  26. Don Bessee Avatar
    Don Bessee

    With your history of prognostication one would think you would give it up! 😉

    Like

  27. Todd Juvinall Avatar
    Todd Juvinall

    Mueller is simply getting a nice salary and wants to make it happen as long as he can. Simple.

    Like

  28. Paul Emery Avatar

    Don
    Do you really think Louie Gohmert can touch Mueller? Really, you’re getting pretty desperate. What do you know about him anyway?

    Like

  29. George Rebane Avatar

    PaulE 722pm – Please read my commentary again. I didn’t say anything about “skate free”, I just ventured that it was unlikely that Mueller had anything yet on Trump since nothing has been leaked. Are you saying that Mueller already has the goods on Trump, and he’s holding back the announcement for an appropriately propitious and maximally damaging moment? Or are we in ‘the investigation will only stop when we finally find the dirt’ phase?

    Like

  30. jon smith Avatar
    jon smith

    Todd 8:10
    “It is the democrat lefty extremists that are wrecking America. We will deal with you soon.”
    Just another 70 year old limp dick threat monger from the right waving his cane and corn cob pipe, declaring that the south will rise again. What do you plan to do Toddy Baby? Boycott Briar Patch?
    Of course we’ll hear nothing but crickets and absolutely zero substance behind your whimpers. Slobber, drool and type meaningless threats while you wet your bed. Good night, old man.

    Like

  31. Don Bessee Avatar
    Don Bessee

    Well that’s so special @ 950. 😉

    Like

  32. Paul Emery Avatar
    Paul Emery

    George we don’t have a clue what Flynn and the others flippers said to get there sweetheart deal. Will find out for sure in time. There’s no way he’s going to fire Mueller

    Like

  33. Don Bessee Avatar
    Don Bessee

    What odds are you giving there ya po’ ol’fakenewsman? 😉

    Like

  34. George Rebane Avatar

    PaulE 1034pm – Huh?!

    Like

  35. Bill Tozer Avatar
    Bill Tozer

    Not California’s decay due to Progressive Socialism per se, but still a Left Coast story.
    https://www.seattletimes.com/opinion/after-14-years-ive-had-it-im-leaving-seattle/

    Like

  36. Russ Avatar
    Russ

    As predicted: Slow Death of the Train to Nowhere
    Mounting problems may end high-speed-rail projects in California and Texas.
    A decade ago, high-speed rail was the new, new thing. In 2008, California voters narrowly approved initial bonds for a train that was supposed to go 220 miles an hour and deliver passengers from San Francisco to Los Angeles in two hours and 40 minutes. The next year, the Obama administration’s stimulus bill allocated money for it and several other high-speed lines. But soon the push for trains slowed to a crawl, and now it appears to be on life support.
    In 2011, the new GOP governors of Florida, Ohio, and Wisconsin turned down federal money for trains. Wisconsin’s Scott Walker told me: “Washington may help pay for building it, but we’d be stuck paying the operating costs of a boondoggle.”
    https://www.nationalreview.com/2018/04/high-speed-rail-projects-face-growing-criticism-roadblocks/
    The sooner, the better. The track and the towers it is built on will become the CA Stonehenge

    Like

  37. Todd Juvinall Avatar
    Todd Juvinall

    Russ I was wondering how the train initiative could say LA to SF and then end up Chowchilla to Fresno. That alone is bait and switch and is illegal I thought.

    Like

  38. scenes Avatar
    scenes

    Russ@8:26AM
    Well, sir, there’s nothing on earth
    Like a genuine, bona fide
    Electrified, six-car monorail

    Like

  39. jon smith Avatar
    jon smith

    Monuments of failure spurred by the draw, shoot, aim crowd. Foresthill Bridge. High speed rail and Delta tunnels to follow.

    Like

  40. Paul Emery Avatar

    RE George 10:34 George writes:
    “if it exists, would have been leaked months ago?”
    My point is we don’t know what Mueller has learned and what the flippers have told him in exchange for their easy sentencing. IT WILL COME OUT. MUELLER WILL NOT BE FIRED. THAT WOULD BE SUICIDE FOR TRUMP!

    Like

  41. Archie Avatar
    Archie

    @GeorgeR – funny how you use income inequality as an example of California’s progressive socialism. I would have imagined that the rich getting richer and the poor getting poorer would be the result of a capitalist or corporatist enabled environment.
    Do tell.

    Like

  42. Gregory Avatar
    Gregory

    Here it is, 1 May 2018, and Trump is still unscathed. No charges, no resignation.
    But the kids are still in their sleepers, sure that Santa will be arriving with their presents any minute now.

    Like

  43. scenes Avatar
    scenes

    Archie@12:15PM
    Why on earth would you think that socialist governments produce more equity in income?
    A beautiful case in point is the USSR in the post-war period. Income inequity was much higher than it is (or was) in the West. When you have a single body determining who gets what, guess what happens?

    Like

  44. George Rebane Avatar

    Archie 1215pm – Sir, you really are an embarrassment to yourself. Even a smidgen of reading would reveal that to you. Meditate on scenes’ 112pm – it was ever thus.
    PaulE 1212pm – And you missed my point, which is if Mueller really had something it would have already been leaked. Check out Lerner & Loewe, you’re singing their song, and it’s the only one you and yours have.

    Like

  45. Archie Avatar
    Archie

    Scenes and GeorgeR – nice try.
    The USSR does not exist. It failed.
    “Income inequity was much higher than it is (or was) in the West.” – ok, so you are saying there is inequity in both capitalism and socialism. And you are saying capitalism as practiced today in the US where 95% of the income goes to the top 1% is the perfect system, except for California where socialism is practiced?
    Where are these mythical evil egalitarian socialist societies?
    Are they some of these?
    https://www.theguardian.com/inequality/datablog/2017/apr/26/inequality-index-where-are-the-worlds-most-unequal-countries

    Like

  46. Archie Avatar
    Archie

    It is all California’s fault.
    “As it happens, the U.S. has one of the most unequal income distributions in the developed world, according to data from the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development — even after taxes and social-welfare policies are taken into account.”
    http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2013/12/19/global-inequality-how-the-u-s-compares/

    Like

  47. Marillyn Lock-Heed Avatar
    Marillyn Lock-Heed

    More bad news here for Scenes and GeorgeR,
    http://fortune.com/2014/10/31/inequality-wealth-income-us/

    Like

  48. George Rebane Avatar

    MarilynnL 343pm – I am truly sorry that RR is way too complex for you Ms Lock. No one here has maintained that free market capitalism would eliminate wealth inequality – it’s exactly the other way around, wealth inequality would be increased as those that can pull away from those that can’t or won’t. That’s one of the political weaknesses of the conservetarian ideology. The strength, also invisible to you, is that given free market capitalism, those on the lowest rungs of the economic ladder have and will continue to enjoy a QoL that in the recent past they would have considered impossible if they continued to believe their socialist betters, and they have the mobility to better their lot. To the extent that people have avoided tyranny and/or the stultifying hand of collectivism, it’s been that way ever since free market capitalism was discovered in the Low Countries during the Renaissance.
    But fret not, there’s another blog hereabouts that deals in much more accessible topics and viewpoints. Should you be interested, any of our other readers could point you to it.

    Like

  49. Paul Emery Avatar

    George
    It is you song that has a skimpy story line. The only assurances you have that there is nothing Mueller has on Trump is the assumption that it doesn’t exist or it would have been leaked. Mueller team leaks have been very skimpy and most speculation is that the recent list of questions Muller allegedly would ask Trump comes from a leak from the Trump team or someone affiliated with his defense team. There are so many ex’s on that team that it could be any one of dozens who have been dumped or fired.

    Like

Leave a comment