Rebane's Ruminations
January 2018
S M T W T F S
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031  

ARCHIVES


OUR LINKS


YubaNet
White House Blog
Watts Up With That?
The Union
Sierra Thread
RL “Bob” Crabb
Barry Pruett Blog

George Rebane

The 2018 Tax Reform Act is legislation that I believe will overall reduce taxes for almost all Americans, and with its business-friendly provisions will give a significant boost to GDP growth.  However, its SALT (state and local taxes) provision disturbs me because it is intrinsically flawed both functionally and, yes, ethically.  The latter because it allows the various taxing jurisdictions to make the wage earner pay more in taxes than the total amount he earned.  SALT bases its tax amounts on the total amount earned before any other mandated taxes, fees, and tributes are paid.  If all taxing jurisdictions practice SALT – say local rate is 25%, state rate is 35%, federal rate is 45% – then the taxpayer may wind up owing more than a 100% of his earnings in taxes.  Such policies are intrinsically unfair and unethical.  The jurisdictions should decide their sequence of taxation – say, first local then state then federal – and each apply their rates to the amount that the taxpayer has left after paying his prior tax obligations.  That way the total taxes may approach 100%, but they will never exceed it like in the above example where the taxes sum to 105% of earnings.

America’s Left either does not understand the use of force by nations, or is consciously working to have our country capitulate to or be destroyed by a foreign power.  As outlined most recently in ‘America’s Checkpoints’, I believe in the former.  It is unconscionable that Democrats like Schumer and Pelosi will hold defense upgrades hostage to their vote buying spending programs.  Without a formidable military feared by our enemies, diplomacy sings castrato.  In short, without credible arms there will be no United States to earn the redistributed monies for our entitlement programs.  And the Left knows this as it plays brinkmanship with what should be a non-partisan funding priority were we truly all Americans.  Mark Helprin of the Claremont Institute lays out the details of the current dire situation in his ‘America’s Alarmingly Archaic Arsenal’.

And jumping from perfidy to insanity, the Left’s class warfare and identity politics cadres have come up with a new one for the campus wars, soon to be seen on a lamestream commentary near you.  The core contention in understanding the new black-white dialogue on campuses is, “One, that civility, as currently practiced in America, is a white construct. Two, that in a campus setting, the “woke” white student’s endeavor to avoid microaggressions against black peers is itself a microaggression—a form of noblesse oblige whereby white students are in fact patronizing students of color. Not only that, but by treating black students with common courtesy and expecting the same in return, white students elide black grievances, bypassing the “race talk” that is supposed to occur in preamble to all other conversations. Got it?”

And it gets worse in the context of reasoned debates in which reason is now considered racist.  So, “increasingly at major competitions, there must be a pre-debate debate on the terms of engagement: whether students are required to cite proof or are free to argue wholly from their feelings and so-called lived experience. Far from being banned or even maligned by debate judges, such antics increasingly win converts and, not coincidentally, matches.”  And there is no requirement that your “lived experience” bears any resemblance to the real world.  “Students are pointedly discouraged from rebutting feelings that don’t jibe with verifiable reality.”  (more here)

Posted in , , ,

95 responses to “Scattershots – 4jan18”

  1. Todd Juvinall Avatar
    Todd Juvinall

    100 years ago the country stopped immigration until those eastern folks assimilated.

    Like

  2. Bill Tozer Avatar

    Punchy, what worked in the past does not mean it will work now. The illegals and “Kenyan farmers” have taken the jobs that the former Ellis Island immigrants did. Roofers, carpenters,, hospitality services, darn near every worker inside meat packing plants, and on and on it goes.
    We NEEDED the “1914” wave to built our cities and build the expansion of our country. Industrial Revolution stuff. Those jobs are disappearing. At least Reagen had a big manufacturing base to revive. The manufacturing sector has shrunk since the good old days.
    Again, how is that guy in the mud hut going to make it CA or any US state in this expensive to live day and age? Statue says bring us your homeless. Think we have our hands full of homeless right now. Is the Hospitality House ready for 60 more? Eh? 1914 was right around WW1; wadn’t it. Think I had one come over around 1918 and another one from Greenland of all balances. Ran, then bought, a boarding house in Chicago or someplace. Died in Ann Arbor. Those days are gone. Have you seen housin prices lately?
    The Righties judge success by how many folks secure employment. The Lefties judge success as how many of the huddled masses they can put on the welfare rolls…er…take care of.
    GOD: Good Orderly Direction. Get the policy right, clearly laid out and put down in writing first. Always America First. This ain’t open mike amateur night nor an All Comers 10k run. We are talking about a good orderly direction with specific criteria for qualify to even begin the application process.

    Like

  3. ScenesFromTheApocalypse Avatar
    ScenesFromTheApocalypse

    re: PaulE
    Of course the rest of the Third World wants to move here. Just imagine if the borders were truly open and anyone with a plane ticket could move in. The US wouldn’t last 10 years. Given your lack of concern for existing US citizens, I’m not sure that your grandparents did me a favor here.
    The poem on the Statue of Liberty has nothing to do with the statue of course. It was written for the base some time later. No doubt you’ll immediately forget that factoid in a minute or two. Interestingly, the author was a strong Zionist, so I guess her interest in people moving into someone else’s property extended elsewhere.
    Late 19th C. (and very early 20th) immigration had enough negative effects on the country that a couple of bits of legislation were passed. Here’s one:
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_Act_of_1924
    In any case, I can’t say that any of my questions were answered, but then what’s new?
    I’ll give you my opinion. The US should invite the highest functioning people, strongly urge them to integrate rather than gather in ethnic communities, and should generally act in the best interest of existing citizens. If this means that everyone comes from Norway, that’s fine. As usual, aside from the well known social problems you get from a diverse and non-integrated state, population growth for growth’s sake is just plain stupid. There’ll always be an ever growing crowd outside the gate, at least until the inevitable Malthusian overshoot occurs in places like sub-Saharan Africa.
    Take a minute and consider this chart, my nom de plume was chosen for a reason.
    https://www.unzcloud.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/Population-1950-2100-b.png

    Like

  4. Paul Emery Avatar
    Paul Emery

    Trump is an outright racist as is anyone who attempts to defend his views that
    “Why are we having all these people from shithole countries come here?”
    “should have more people from places like Norway,”

    Like

  5. Paul Emery Avatar
    Paul Emery

    Do you have a list of “shit hole countries” Scenes that could serve as a guide for allowing entry to this country? What in your view qualifies a country as being a shit hole country?

    Like

  6. Don Bessee Avatar
    Don Bessee

    How typically lefty of the po’ ol’ fakenewsman. Nooooooooo we don’t want well educated stable immigrants who wont be a burden on taxpayers, he would rather have illiterate goat herders on our dime (he probably gets the earned income tax credit) is really what he is saying @921. 😉

    Like

  7. Paul Emery Avatar
    Paul Emery

    Can you name a few shit hole countries Don?

    Like

  8. Bill Tozer Avatar

    AWhy, why, why?
    1) Because half on the billion that want to come here today are illiterate in their native tanguages. That’s why. Vancouver don’t have Mexicans, they have the Sri Lankan’s to clean your bedpans and change hotel sheets and towels.
    2) Because they ARE shithole countries. One needs to get out more often.
    3) Bonus answer. Because we are a big bad bunch of racists, that’s why! Did I get the answer right, did I Wally? Oh goodie goodie gumdrops, what prize did I win? How silly of me to not think of THAT obvious answer first. I am such a dufus.
    https://www.facebook.com/RowdyConservatives/photos/a.217983685002343.55586.217926015008110/1236433246490710/?type=3&theater

    Like

  9. Don Bessee Avatar
    Don Bessee

    Why, why, why? @ 935. 😉

    Like

  10. Don Bessee Avatar
    Don Bessee

    Here is a list of shit holes for the po’ ol’ fakenewsman from those racists at the UN.
    https://www.un.org/development/desa/dpad/least-developed-country-category/ldcs-at-a-glance.html
    😉

    Like

  11. Don Bessee Avatar
    Don Bessee

    Emery?? Emery?? Emery?? 😉

    Like

  12. Paul Emery Avatar
    Paul Emery

    Don
    So Nepal is a shit hole Country Don. Perhaps you should meet a friend of mine who works at Bonanza market who is an immigrant from Nepal Would you like to do that?

    Like

  13. Bill Tozer Avatar

    Bring us the best. Punchy’s friend speaks English. That’s a great start. Good. Start.
    Cuban is another shithole, so is Venezuela and the Congo. Puerto Rico is not a country, but all are a hell lot better than Haiti.

    Like

  14. Bill Tozer Avatar

    Just put them all in line and let them show us what they bring to the table. Criminal history, education levels (hopefully past 6th grade), are they pregnant, have a US sponsor, age (26-42 preferred) skills we need, know a trade, prior employment history, documents to verify…those kind of things. We be completely colorblind. Lay out those cards on the table and let’s see who qualifies to stand in the next line to the right. Then, wait.

    Like

  15. Don Bessee Avatar
    Don Bessee

    According to the UN its a shit hole so take it up with them. That is if they even talk to likes of po’ ol’ fakenewsmen. LOL 😉

    Like

  16. Bill Tozer Avatar

    7 year wait to be allowed in is fair.
    I know some that spent 11, 13-17 years before being allowed in to stay. One guy I met getting gold out of them here hillsand welcomed in my camp to socialize and sleep under the stars for awhile was from Poland or some Eastern European country. He dreamed of coming to America. He acquired some skills and education, moved to South America and became a citizen of that country solely because that country in South America (Brazil, I believe) was easier to get into the US from than from Eastern Europe at the time….a 17 year journey for him and his nuclear family and worth every second of the whole long journey according to him. Forget his name. Good guy, as far as I could tell. We do give preferences to certain regions.
    It was George W Bush that surprisingly really put the push on for opening up African countries for immigration. A kinder gentler America. A Thousand Points of Light and all that stuff.
    Bush lied, people died! 🙂

    Like

  17. Don Bessee Avatar
    Don Bessee

    OH NO! Here come the po’ ol’ bush derangement syndrome! 😉

    Like

  18. Walt Avatar

    LOL Paul If it was great,, why they leave?

    Like

  19. Don Bessee Avatar
    Don Bessee

    Remember the intent?
    http://www.breitbart.com/big-government/2015/03/30/ted-kennedys-real-legacy-50-years-of-ruinous-immigration-law/
    First, our cities will not be flooded with a million immigrants annually. Under the proposed bill, the present level of immigration remains substantially the same…
    Secondly, the ethnic mix of this country will not be upset… Contrary to the charges in some quarters, [the bill] will not inundate America with immigrants from any one country or area, or the most populated and deprived nations of Africa and Asia…
    In the final analysis, the ethnic pattern of immigration under the proposed measure is not expected to change as sharply as the critics seem to think… The bill will not flood our cities with immigrants. It will not upset the ethnic mix of our society. It will not relax the standards of admission. It will not cause American workers to lose their jobs.”
    😉

    Like

  20. George Rebane Avatar

    This dialogue with a liberal about farmers and shit hole countries is priceless. It is a poster child illustration of how two sides glibly talk past each other with no hope of even agreeing on the format and topic of conversation.
    Anyone want to make an attempt at reason and offer a definition of ‘shit hole country’ beyond just ‘I know one when I see it.’?

    Like

  21. Bill Toze Avatar

    Oh Don
    Breitbart? Really, Don, how could you? Breitbart just dumped the Libbies new hero (some White Nationalist guy) and has more daily hits than the Drudge Report. Can’t believe a word they say. Fake news. Breitbart?
    Perhaps NPR would be a more palatable read to those with discriminating tastes.
    https://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=5391395

    Like

  22. Don Bessee Avatar
    Don Bessee

    Dr. R, I would submit my 943 as exhibit 1 for establishing a base line shit hole standard. 😉

    Like

  23. Bill Toze Avatar

    Just do you own research on Pine Ridge Reservation. That is a good place to start on what constitutes a shithole country. First Nations qualify as countries, right? I emigrated from there. One will find a amazing parallel to Haiti in some many categories…infant morality rate, life expectancy, drop out rates, suicide rates, per capita annual income, access to landlines, drug and alcohol abuse/deaths, economic opportunities. Some score better than Haiti, some below Haiti. Only thing I can say is Custer plenty blew Big Horn. Not much else to boast about….as a country, not a people.

    Like

  24. Bill Toze Avatar

    The libs would probably say “The Vatican”. To be continued…… Nappy-Pooh time.
    That Trump is something else. Always pushes the conservation forward. Quite provocative..

    Like

  25. Bill Tozer (moi) Avatar

    Short nap. Now, how in the Sam Hill did this thread get so off topic? Hmmm. Oh yeah.
    1) Even Ann Coulter is pulling the plug on Trump and questioning his IQ. From Todds favorite website Breitbart.
    “Trump was more than willing to sell out the base to solve a personal problem of his — the Michael Wolff book — but managed to not convince a single American that he’s articulate, bright, or a good leader.”
    Posted by: Paul Emery | 10 January 2018 at 06:30 PM
    Followed by his very next comment the following afternoon
    2) Then if Trump is not indicted thye Dems will be in a good position for impeachment for obstruction of justice.
    Posted by: Paul Emery | 11 January 2018 at 02:20 PM
    Followed just two comments and 42 minutes later by:
    3). Trump, what a racist pig
    Posted by: Paul Emery | 11 January 2018 at 03:02 PM
    Hmmm. Guess that just about covers all the bases. Timelines of TDS are kind of fun. My, my. Somebody has free rent in somebody’s head.
    But, what triggered these insightful comments? Oh yeah, it was that horrid Ann Coulter who started it all.
    https://www.facebook.com/lastamericapatriots/photos/a.235087906641439.1073741826.235086849974878/979261335557422/?type=3&theater

    Like

  26. Scenes Avatar
    Scenes

    GRebane: “This dialogue with a liberal about farmers and shit hole countries is priceless. ”
    C’est la vie. The liberal lives in a whiteopia but emits an endless stream of virtue signals. My best guess is that he carries an internal fantasy of proudly leading millions of third worlders into the light while proudly carrying a ‘Welcome Refugees’ banner.
    KVMR can cover the hilarity that ensues as News Jesus leads the multitudes.
    I suppose that the shithole country moniker isn’t so hard to earn
    http://www.news-world.us/pics/60-worst-countries-in-the-world/
    although it’s pretty obvious that the most straightforward immigration would come from the Five Eyes countries.
    Taking the more practical tack that a country should import people who actually make it better off forces you to deal with individuals, and perhaps their immediate families (as opposed to the chain migration fiasco). High grading the world is like self-interested trade and foreign policy, a smart move. Perhaps a combination of investor visas, education requirements and/or something like a traditional Chinese civil service exam would be enough ..along with a criminal background check of course.
    In any case, given demographic pressures and an increasing wealth gradient, you can build the ‘wall’ now or build it later. The longer you wait, the uglier it’s going to be.

    Like

  27. Scenes Avatar
    Scenes

    re: A quick theory on xenophilia and the strong need for moar and moar immigrants.
    It occurs to me that this isn’t so much about the need to improve the USA (obviously) or even to improve the lives of everyone in the rest of the world, but is simply the weaponization of masses of people.
    What might be at work here isn’t a tactical move by the Democrats for votes, or huge love for Somali/Syrian/Guatemalan/Nigerian/Haitian culture by the Green Libertarians, but is a need by those same GL’s to punish the folks that they hate. They’ve identified a move that hits pro-Western people at a gut level and will continue until morale improves. Even when there’s no advantage to yourself, squeezing an enemy hard has it’s own value.

    Like

  28. fish Avatar
    fish

    Posted by: Scenes | 12 January 2018 at 07:18 AM
    What might be at work here isn’t a tactical move by the Democrats for votes, or huge love for Somali/Syrian/Guatemalan/Nigerian/Haitian culture by the Green Libertarians, but is a need by those same GL’s to punish the folks that they hate. They’ve identified a move that hits pro-Western people at a gut level and will continue until morale improves. Even when there’s no advantage to yourself, squeezing an enemy hard has it’s own value.

    You think this is the primary reason?

    Like

  29. Scenes from the Apocalypse Avatar
    Scenes from the Apocalypse

    re: Fish@8:21
    I couldn’t be sure, but I don’t doubt there’s at least a Christopher Matthews leg tingle when they see one of those pictures from Europe and think of the consternation it’ll cause.
    One thing nice about ‘shithole countries’ is that if you are forced to say they aren’t shitholes, you don’t feel bad sending people back to them.

    Like

  30. fish Avatar
    fish

    Posted by: Scenes from the Apocalypse | 12 January 2018 at 08:52 AM
    One thing nice about ‘shithole countries’ is that if you are forced to say they aren’t shitholes, you don’t feel bad sending people back to them.

    Or letting them in in the first place.
    Any way I’m still not convinced that your earlier statement is accurate. The importation of a permanent underclass provides for so much practical advantages for the bi-factional ruling class I can’t help but think that the notion of “sticking it to those they hate” is merely the cherry on the sundae!

    Like

  31. George Rebane Avatar

    Administrivia – An excellent discussion opening on the SHCs – the newest thread and most relevant thread on immigration so far. If you give me a bit this morning, I will post my own loosely coagulated thoughts in a dedicated post on the SHC topic that is guaranteed not to go away any time soon. Hopefully, this will serve to focus further discussion in a compact and searchable topic area on RR. Thanks.

    Like

  32. fish Avatar
    fish

    Posted by: George Rebane | 12 January 2018 at 09:29 AM
    Looking forward to it.

    Like

  33. fish Avatar
    fish

    Likely why “Shithole Country” comments will be forgotten in about 12 hours!

    Was Fusion GPS Allowed to Run Unsupervised FISA-702 Queries?


    We interrupt our regularly-scheduled LinkSwarm, and preempt our next gargantuan Clinton Corruption update, to bring you a development that potentially dwarfs not only what we already know of the scandal, but any national American political scandal since Benedict Arnold sold the British the plans to West Point in 1780.
    These claims center around a Top Secret FISA Court Order document obtained by Judicial Watch on May 23, 2017, but I first came across them last night on Twitter:

    https://www.battleswarmblog.com/?p=34867

    Like

  34. Todd Juvinall Avatar
    Todd Juvinall

    Brian Hamilton is threatening me with banishment from their FB and comments section because I have the temerity to respond to the personal attacks they allow against moi. The liberals are jamming his email with complaints that I defend myself.

    Like

  35. fish Avatar
    fish

    Posted by: Todd Juvinall | 12 January 2018 at 10:10 AM
    What do you care Todd?
    That’s just how progressives play! They stick their fingers in their ears and go…..la la la I can’t hear you when confronted with thoughts and ideas they don’t like.

    Like

  36. Walt Avatar

    Fish!! How come DiFi didn’t let that cat out of the bag?
    Bastards!!!

    Like

  37. fish Avatar
    fish

    Posted by: Walt | 12 January 2018 at 10:24 AM
    Well I understand that she has a pretty nasty case of the sniffles Walt! Or she’s senile.
    Up to the reader to decide!

    Like

  38. Todd Juvinall Avatar
    Todd Juvinall

    FISH I was silent for years while the left attacked me and my family personally and tried to destroy my business. Hell, this week a fool on the Union FB contacted my daughter off my FB page to see if a was telling the truth about drinking. Creepy! Anyway, the Union leaves the lib fools attacks on me and wants to boot me. Maybe you all could send Hamilton and Rogers support for me and derision for my attackers. LOL!

    Like

  39. fish Avatar
    fish

    Posted by: Todd Juvinall | 12 January 2018 at 10:33 AM
    If you are going to have strong opinions Todd you shouldn’t be surprised by this!

    Like

  40. Bill Tozer (moi) Avatar

    Just passing some time waiting for Dr. Rebane’s newest shithole post. 😉
    Amidst the outrage of President Trump accurate accessment of Haiti, El Salvador, and (some) African nations, I have yet to hear one of the representatives from aforementioned countries vigorously argue their countries are not shitholes, but in reality paradises.
    Ambassadors from various African counties have contacted our US ambassadors to inquire if Trump was including their actual country in the other African nations Shitholes.. Guess nobody wants to be branded by Trump. Those names and images stick. Just ask Low Enegy Jeb, Crooked Hillary, Pocahontas, Little Marco, Rocketman, Shithole Sudan…. Yep, no country wants to labeled as a war torn, corrupt, civil rights stomping tin horn dictatorship banana republic shithole.
    Ok, prove you are not from a shithole. Talking to you, yes you, Congresswomen representing Detroit.
    https://www.facebook.com/lastamericapatriots/photos/a.235087906641439.1073741826.235086849974878/980960612054161/?type=3&theater
    https://www.facebook.com/RowdyConservatives/photos/a.217983685002343.55586.217926015008110/1234591563341545/?type=3&theater
    One for the road.
    https://www.facebook.com/RowdyConservatives/photos/a.217983685002343.55586.217926015008110/1236234723177229/?type=3&theater

    Like

  41. Walt Avatar

    Exhibit A
    https://news.trust.org/item/20180112035017-q9adf
    “SAN CRISTOBAL/BARINAS, Venezuela, Jan 11 (Reuters) – Hungry mobs ransacked a food collection center, and a supermarket in Venezuela’s western Andean state of Merida on Thursday and reportedly even slaughtered cattle grazing in a field as unrest over food shortages spread through the country.
    An opposition lawmaker from Merida, Carlos Paparoni, said four people had died and 10 were injured in the chaos over the last two days, but he did not specify the circumstances.”
    Yes,, S.Hole…..

    Like

  42. George Rebane Avatar

    The SHC post is now up and awaiting your tender mercies. Onward!

    Like

  43. Bill Tozer (moi) Avatar

    Oh Todd, you bully you. 🙂 I have been kicked off a lot better sites than The Union. By employing some minor cyberspace hocus locus adjustments, lo and behold, I can post there again…..but I have more than lost but a lukewarm interest to do so. Go figure.
    Bottomline: The only thing they remember is not what you said, but how you said it. You are a meanie. Another thing I am realizing. The Left has the complete utter inability to see any of their own hypocrisy, duplicity, irony, paradoxical actions; you get the point. They just absolutely do not possess the capacity to process that information. It does not compute. I wasted too much time pointing out their hypocrisy to them, but it never penetrates even 1/0000 of a millimeter. Might as well try and catch the wind.
    I personally feel it is generally a bad idea to argue on FB….about almost everything.
    Silence is golden, duct tape is silver. 🙂

    Like

Leave a comment