George Rebane
I sent the following letter to The Union after reading the latest ‘resistance is futile’ offering from a well-meaning neighbor in Auburn.
***
Mr Gregg Littell’s thoughtful 7nov15 piece, ‘The idea of 'armed rebellion' in the U.S. is ludicrous’, disturbs on several counts. First and foremost his arguments ignore historical and ongoing realities. More distressingly he paints a hopeless picture for humanity since tyranny is the most easily attainable and stable form of governance known – tyrannies replace tyrannies ad nauseum. With an armed populace the American Revolution showed humanity how it could answer ‘Can man govern himself?’ with a resounding YES!
Today, after decades of meticulous preparation, the American leviathan is in rapid ascent toward global governance with half of us applauding its progress. Mr Littell’s hopeless analysis of the futility of armed resistance is contradicted by all autocratic governments, joined now by America, that acknowledge disarming its citizens is the sine qua non necessary and sufficient precondition to a centrally planned state with a compliant population. Ultimately America’s freedoms will be reinstated and preserved by a newly educated citizenry that rejects a carefully crafted imperious America, and instead sees a truly exceptional nation that has delivered by far the most wealth, enlightenment, and hope to the world’s poor and oppressed. My blog has a more complete response to Mr Littell’s counsel.
***
Of course there is much more to be said about the ‘futility notion’, and RR readers and I have pretty well covered the waterfront on these pages over the last eight years. The Union’s 200-word letter limit didn’t allow me to add the following for their readers which here I summarize in a painfully abbreviated set of points. Hopefully our learned and well-read readers can recall the appropriately extended arguments.
- Our military must be trained to pursue and fire on Americans in America. Every veteran knows that subversion of our military by America’s future tyrant will take time and be very visible as witnessed by the newly inaugurated Jade Helm joint military/police annual exercises.
- Our military must act in unison in service of tyranny, no fractionation of loyalty to government and rebels, else a civil war ensues.
- Successful civil disobedience must be unified, concurrent, and overwhelming. This is extremely difficult under an all-seeing tyrant. Nazis hanging conquered eastern Europeans by the dozens in city squares successfully thwarted piecemeal (armed and unarmed) resistance.
- In the last 100 years there are many examples of successful citizen rebellions that were initially outgunned by their governments.
- Rebels will not be limited to small arms once rebellion starts. The ability to access and incorporate modern technology to perform advanced command/control, sensing, surveillance, and weapon guidance functions will be ubiquitous, especially in a technologically advanced country like the US.
- The telling argument against the ‘it is futile’ crowd is that if Leviathan were not worried about a successful rebellion that starts with broad-based ownership of small arms, it and its loyal lackeys would not be working day and night to make the ownership and use of guns more difficult (using all kinds of ‘gun safety’ arguments, but never touching the function of guns for a free society – trigger warning to progressives: don’t use the old pap of how EU countries do without liberal gun ownership, they have the US to let them play with such social policies).
- The US government ist already worried about citizen armed resistance – refer to the threat list published by the DHS and now the launch of the annual Jade Helm military/police joint exercises.
- Multiple generations have been taught in union schools that America 1) is not exceptional, and 2) is an evil empire come of age in the New World (these pages contain ample evidence of such opinions)
- Founders wrote 2nd Amendment based on the concept of citizens’ ‘par force’ that would check a future rogue government. While the basic idea remains fundamental, it has been weakened by the constant addition of regulations that impede/proscribe gun ownership and use.
- Constraining America’s salvation to be guaranteed through only mass re-education promotes the odds of an incipient dictatorship, and that in the interval we can make do by remaining ‘ignorant and free’.
- Jefferson’s dictum is already violate. The disappearance of our freedoms are easily understood through the parable of the slowly parboiled frogs as the existential proof that ignorance and freedom cannot long coexist.
BTW, I was amused to see Mr Littell’s us of “A nation ignorant and free, that never was and never will (shall) be.” The meme seems to be getting around. It was in the 1990s when I wordsmithed that abbreviation of Thomas Jefferson’s famous insight that he included in one of his collected letters. At the time I was lecturing at CSU Northridge in their mass communications school (integration of journalism and media producers) where I wound up as Adjunct Professor teaching their core class in critical thinking that I’ve described elsewhere in these pages. Before the beginning of every lecture I would write at the top of the blackboard ‘A nation ignorant and free, that never was and never shall be.’ Thomas Jefferson. Preventing that fate that was my students’ charter, and the compelling principle motivating their studies. My first online use of it was in 2005 on Russ Steele’s NC Media Watch blog which he kindly invited me to co-author with him before I started RR. Would love to know if anyone can find an earlier than 1995 citation of that form of Jefferson’s dictum.
rebanesruminations.com 
Leave a comment