Rebane's Ruminations
September 2015
S M T W T F S
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
27282930  

ARCHIVES


OUR LINKS


YubaNet
White House Blog
Watts Up With That?
The Union
Sierra Thread
RL “Bob” Crabb
Barry Pruett Blog

George Rebane

[This is the transcript of my regular KVMR commentary broadcast on 1 October 2015, not 30 September as previously noted.]

For over two centuries America has had the reputation as being exceptional in the freedoms granted its citizens and guaranteed by its constitution.  However things have changed over the last 50 years or so, and few Americans are aware of it.  Our personal and economic freedoms have taken a dive which has gone unreported by the left-leaning lamestream media, and therefore unknown to those who limit their news to such outlets.  You are fortunate that KVMR is not among them.

Recently some thought provoking studies have been published which put the United States into perspective with other developed countries, and the resulting picture is not pretty.  But the findings do go a long way to explain the economic and social degradation we experience in the β€œland of the free and the home of the brave.”


The libertarian Cato Institute recently published its massive and heavily documented β€˜Human Freedom Index’ made up of the Personal Freedom and Economic Freedom Indexes.  These are based on 76 distinct indicators of personal and economic freedom in areas such as β€˜Rule of Law’, β€˜Security and Safety’, β€˜Movement’, β€˜Legal System and Property Rights’, β€˜Regulation of Credit, Labor, and Business’, and so on.

Now here comes the part where you want to check your seatbelts.  America ranks 20th in the world on the overall Human Freedom Index.  There the top five freest countries are Hong Kong, Switzerland, Finland, Denmark, and New Zealand.  Almost every country that most of us consider advanced ranks ahead of us.  But the sadder part is in the constituent Personal Freedom index; there America ranks 31st.  This is not a surprise to those of us with enough birthdays.  We have witnessed the slow erosion of our freedoms over the last few decades as the Leviathan continues to lay on the burden of more laws, regulations, and codes.

On the Economic Freedom index we rank 12th.  But even that is now a position in flux as our country’s business tax load drives more and more companies to take their operations overseas.  To this we add the just released annual International Tax Competitiveness Index by the non-partisan Tax Foundation that ranks the US a β€œdismal 32nd out of 34 industrialized nations.”  The Baltic nation Estonia β€œagain enjoys the top overall ranking in this year’s index.”  And things will definitely get worse if progressive policies today promised by the Left are added to those that got us here.  With these policies the new normal for our economic growth will be below 2%, and that not only hurts the mostly poor and under-educated, but also makes them more prone than ever to vote to continue this vicious cycle.

What seems to promote our insane public policies most is the government’s synchronized destruction of America’s families along with our public education system.  Both liberal and conservative institutions studying the problem agree that β€œthe goal is to encourage work and move people from school or unemployment into the work force, not to channel resources on the basis of need.”  In other words naked wealth transfers and redistribution has not worked, and does not work with the incentives it sets up for people to simply get a job, or form traditional two-parent families that support their children’s education. Within our over-regulated social system and perverse tax codes, the penalty for making the right decisions today is just too high, with promises in place to make it higher still.  The bottom line is that social and economic opportunities rise and fall together.  Family lives also matter, and the attempt to solve social problems while hobbling the economy will only continue our downward spiral as is evident by how we measure our place in the community of nations.  (see 'The Inequality Cycle')

Ignoring our performance and taking other people’s money to fix all of our ills got us here, and drinking more of that Kool-Aid will not help.  But the real tragedy is that most people have no sense of how much our independence, industry, and initiative has already been depleted by the uncounted number of small cuts made daily by the central planners of Washington and Sacramento. 

My name is Rebane, and I also expand on this and related themes on Rebane’s Ruminations where the transcript of this commentary is posted with relevant links, and where such issues are debated extensively.  However my views are not necessarily shared by KVMR.  Thank you for listening.

Posted in , , ,

46 responses to “How Free is America?”

  1. Paul Emery Avatar
    Paul Emery

    Finland and Denmark in the top five. These are by your definition deeply Socialistic countries. Apparently that hasn’t affected their “human freedom index”. Also, all of the top five have universal health care for all and dramatically progressive income tax (Hong Cong possible exception)

    Like

  2. George Rebane Avatar

    PaulE 645pm – Finland and Denmark are small countries with stagnant populations of under 5M, culturally extremely cohesive, no business formation to speak of, and with stultifying economies that are growing at less that 0.5% annually (really!!). They both admit that their lavish entitlement and social programs (especially healthcare) are not sustainable, and are looking for solutions on how to wean their populations. Were we to have these parameters (which may occur shortly given what you and yours are bringing us), then there would be blood in the streets. Check it out.

    Like

  3. Paul Emery Avatar
    Paul Emery

    AS to the question at hand your personal opinion of the future is nothing more than your opinion. What is verifiable fact is that according to the standards you cite that paint a gloomy scenario for this country, they have a much higher “human freedom index’ than we do according to the Cato Institute.
    Blood in the streets? Really George!

    Like

  4. Don Bessee Avatar
    Don Bessee

    nypost.com/2015/09/29/obamacares-latest-victims-100000-new-yorkers-and-taxpayers-everywhere A little dose of reality for the socialists and 0 who said we don’t need no stikin actuaries. Just like the no doc loans that Barny Frank and slick willie forced on the banks ‘for the American dream’ for everyone no matter how unqualified the borrower or inadequate security was the property. We all know how well those socialist ideas worked to set up the crash.

    Like

  5. Todd Juvinall Avatar
    Todd Juvinall

    I say ship in a couple of million Syrians to Denmark and Finland since they are bereft of people of color and make them as diverse as the USA. Maybe send Paul Emery there to run the place. I’s buy 100 tickets for that endeavor. LOL!

    Like

  6. Don Bessee Avatar
    Don Bessee

    Those guys have slashed the benefits for ‘refugees’ that’s why they are not mentioned by the military age guys flooding the southern European states. They want the big pay days in England, Germany and Sweden. However even Germany has realized so many are just economic refugees and those are going home as in deportation. The pendulum is swinging the other way now. Some but not all European countries need new skilled labor others have no jobs for their own. Its gonna get ugly. How many middle eastern refugees do you think the Russians are going to take? LOL

    Like

  7. George Rebane Avatar

    PaulE 743pm – We are already witness to blood in the streets instigated by how our progressives characterize how our diversity is accepted by the various factions in America. Yes, the problems that socialist policies destroying the country’s ability to create sufficient wealth will create enormous social unrest may be my opinion, but it is widely shared across this nation, including the preparations and policies already in place to handle such disruptions that you can read in the directives and manuals of FEMA and DHS, and we ain’t talking about Muslim terrorists.

    Like

  8. Paul Emery Avatar
    Paul Emery

    Todd, Don, Walt, Gregory
    I think you and all the other freedom lovin’ Conservatives on this blog should move to Denmark, Switzerland or Finland because according to the Cato Institute people there are much more free than they are here. Not so many regulations and lower taxes, less government intrusion. In fact there are thirty some countries according to George that offer more freedom.

    Like

  9. George Rebane Avatar

    PaulE 842pm – Paul, you may have a tin ear, cause you sure ain’t listening or understanding what’s going on. Nobody’s moving to Finland or Denmark, even the Muslim ‘migrants’ running for their lives from the Mideast carnage. And the reason for that is that there is NOTHING there for them – and they all know it, but for some reason you don’t.

    Like

  10. Don Bessee Avatar
    Don Bessee

    The CATO institute really Paul? Less taxes, are you high again? Countries that have less populations than LA are not a metric to follow. Funny you bring the Swiss into the conversation, everyone has an automatic weapon and they are not so cool with immigrants of any kind baring a few million euros to bring into the fold. I am more interested in effecting change in this region and love my country. What service did you volunteer for and serve in again? LOL

    Like

  11. Paul Emery Avatar
    Paul Emery

    Don
    I served six years in the Air Force Reserves. That included six months of active duty and five and a half years of monthly meetings and two weeks active inthe summer. Were you ever in the service?
    George
    So the “freedom index” you quote has noting to do with quality of life. Did I read that right?

    Like

  12. George Rebane Avatar

    PaulE 932pm – I don’t know how you drew that conclusion, please explain.

    Like

  13. Jon Avatar
    Jon

    Don, I’m also curious- being such a documented War Hawk as you are, were you in the service in your earlier days?
    You are really big on sending our young people into harms way in the middle east, that’s pretty clear. So we would really like to know of your military service and sacrifice to our nation. Paul has clearly documented his.
    Thanks.

    Like

  14. Don Bessee Avatar
    Don Bessee

    So what years did you do the reserve duck. It wouldn’t happen to be during the draft would it? I have a couple of boxes of awards and plaques that memorialize my volunteer service to the country, you want to dig through them or see my scars? WOW 2 weeks a summer what a bummer for you to be away from the summer of love. LOL

    Like

  15. George Rebane Avatar

    Gentlemen, you are diverting the conversation from the posted topic. Do it elsewhere.

    Like

  16. Bob Hobert Avatar
    Bob Hobert

    Good luck with this, GR…
    ‘Gentlemen, you are diverting the conversation from the posted topic. Do it elsewhere.’
    I read this blog just often enough to see the same old mindsets permanently set in concrete.

    Like

  17. Paul Emery Avatar
    Paul Emery

    Well George you expressed a certain lamenting for our slippage in the “freedom index” now dominated by socialist, by your definition, countries so I’m assuming quality of life must be better in those places where you have more freedom. Pretty simple. Help me out here if I’m off the track.

    Like

  18. Don Bessee Avatar
    Don Bessee

    Dr. R I have to disagree with you on this one. It is exactly on point that we have some draft ducker and a never served with the potential of self sacrifice telling us we are war hawks. They never put their butt on the line. I have a right to object to their claim for extraordinary freedoms that they did nothing to protect. Understanding the costs of real conflict gives us a perspective that arm chair generals will never understand. Without those willing to step into the real world chance of giving it all for your counties values means we have a perspective that is not just an academic or rhetorical exercise.
    Having an understanding of the real costs of failing to stand up and keep the bigger war from happening is so lost on these people. We have seen the results in the last 7 years. The Russians just told the Poles that they were part of the cause of WWII when it was the NAZIS and USSR who did the dirty deed in the dissection of Poland. Just look at an atlas pre war and now. How free we are is because of the people over the last couple of hundred of years who were not willing to go quietly into the night at the first threat from despots. GOD Bless our active duty volunteers!

    Like

  19. Todd Juvinall Avatar
    Todd Juvinall

    We all grew up with parents who fought to save the world from fascism. Not long after that a group of long haired hippy bastards and their dope smoking women started rioting across the land. Of course those rioters were spoiled little shits and had no love for the sacrifices of their parents. They would be speaking German and a member of the SS if their parents lost. They would have killed all the people of “color” and all the homosexuals just like the Germans did. While many of us were just working and living our lives and raising families, the press made “gods” out of the hippie bastards. Millions of Americans were disgusted with that and elected Nixon in 68 just to try and cleanse the crap the hippy bastards slimed our country with. I have no respect at all for those hippy bastards and their attitudes of disaffection towards their parents. They were scum then and they still are today. Unfortunately our county has many of them. I can’t hardly wait for their obits in the Union.

    Like

  20. Todd Juvinall Avatar
    Todd Juvinall

    Don Bessee | 30 September 2015 at 10:17 PM
    Thank you for your service. I am really proud of you. Your sacrifice was overshadowed by a slimey press corps so draft dodgers could flee to Canada and have Jimmy Carter let them back in. These liberals are now running the government and the schools and they don’t even care you put your life on the line for their sorry asses.

    Like

  21. Jon Avatar
    Jon

    Todd, remind us again of your service to our country.
    Thanks.:)

    Like

  22. Jon Avatar
    Jon

    Paul, don’t you love how Todd just insulted at least half of the good folks of District 1, their friends and their families, yet is delusional enough to think he would have a prayer at challenging for District 1 Supervisor? Unbelievably funny.

    Like

  23. Todd Juvinall Avatar
    Todd Juvinall

    Jon tell us all about your public service and military service.

    Like

  24. Paul Emery Avatar
    Paul Emery

    I love it if Todd ever ran for office and his opponent would use the quotes that he has on this blog He’s like a test tube organism you poke him and he responds Back in his biker days he didn’t even qualify to join a motorcycle club I was around in those days and heard all the stories

    Like

  25. Paul Emery Avatar
    Paul Emery

    Please explain to me how Don Bessee put his life on the line ? As far as I know he never served in the military or was ever a policeman or fireman Perhaps I’m wrong if so correct me.

    Like

  26. Don Bessee Avatar
    Don Bessee

    SO THE ‘JON’ Tell me what Your service was before you game others sock puppet.

    Like

  27. Don Bessee Avatar
    Don Bessee

    Paul Emery again shows his limitations. His world ends at the end of his nose. LOL

    Like

  28. Don Bessee Avatar
    Don Bessee

    Paul, allow me to make it more timely and relevant to Nevada county. I have spent years here fighting for domestic violence victims. As one of the founding Board members of the Court Reformers I have spent literally hundreds and hundreds of hours doing things like escorting domestic violence victims to court and custody exchanges with their tweaking or drug dealer ex’s. Have been attacked (did not go well for them) and threatened with death. In the last decade we have had the criminal set kill one of our cats and a dog. Its not academic to me Mr. Emery.

    Like

  29. Jon Avatar
    Jon

    Still waiting for the War Hawks to describe their MILITARY service. I’m not a War Hawk and have not served in the military. My sister’s fiancΓ© was killed, sadly, incredibly in the last few days of the Vietnam War. Something she never recovered from. That was the last contact my direct family had with military service.
    My father, on the other hand, was a decorated Naval officer supporting the Pacific Fleet in WW2. Based at the Brooklyn Navy Yard, building many if not most of the most important battleships of the war. A proud Veteran, a flag waving American patriot. Before he passed, he expressed his utter disgust at what George W. Bush did to create the utter cluster-fuck we see today in the Middle East. He predicted this mess way back in 2003, starting the night of the Bush-led Baghdad bombing. He kept asking why and shaking his head..I will never forget it. Why are we destroying a major city, a historic and sacred area of the middle east, dropping bombs on a country that has never threatened our nation? Its a fact that the Greatest Generation was mostly disgusted at our actions under Shrub Bush and Dickhead Cheney. These old timers knew our fate with our insane leadership back in 2003…many of them are not around to see the results, and for that I am largely thankful.

    Like

  30. Don Bessee Avatar
    Don Bessee

    My sisters boy friend… blah blah blah. So you have no skin in the game and so no relative input. Thanks the ‘jon’ for confirming what we all knew. So what did the guy who sat high and dry in in NY say about the A bombs on the historical cities being vaporized to save a million American lives? Those were historically significant areas yet necessary. In fact the end game saved millions and millions of Japanese lives should there had to be a land invasion. Again you display you micron thin historical perspective.

    Like

  31. Don Bessee Avatar
    Don Bessee

    Dr. R. the ‘jon’ seems to be to be unacceptably profane in para 2 line 5. It does however seem to be an appropriate description of the poster whoever it is.;-) morninn’ boys.

    Like

  32. Todd Juvinall Avatar
    Todd Juvinall

    “jon” like all liberals takes credit for his relatives service.

    Like

  33. Todd Juvinall Avatar
    Todd Juvinall

    Paul Emery | 30 September 2015 at 10:43 PM
    Now that;s funny. “Biker days” Never owned one. Unlike the the fellow who never had responsibility for having or raising a child (thank goodness for small favors). I was a family man and a employer. My my Paul Emery is jealous. Nothing but heartache there eh Paul Emery? You libs are so sadsack.
    Test tube organism? Well no, I respond to feckless liberals like you because as usual your are always wrong. But hey, my life is good, I am a happy camper and you are not. That is my elixir.

    Like

  34. Jon Avatar
    Jon

    Don, “high and dry”? You have no fucking clue what my father was responsible for, or what he believed about WW2. A hell of a lot more than you’ll ever know about. He supported everything we did in WW2 because the World was imperiled. He was nauseated about Iraq, because it was one big war crime on our part, led by war criminals. Destroying a sovereign nation based on BS and documented dreams of controlling fossil fuel reserves. Millions of Americans are now nauseated about Iraq, and the events of today we set in motion that March day of 2003.

    Like

  35. Todd Juvinall Avatar
    Todd Juvinall

    DonB, as you can see the “jon” wants us to believe he is is worthy because his dad fought in WW2 then spews his commie leftwing talking points about Iraq. You just can’t make this stuff up.

    Like

  36. George Rebane Avatar

    PaulE 1013pm – QoL is not a uniformly understood or measured notion, and it is pretty much dependent on which cohort you are talking about. Small, ethnically homogeneous countries can tolerate enormously more collectivism than large diverse ones – that’s why the USSR and China traveled the road they did. The happy Danes and Finns are grandfathered in and into a lifestyle that is acceptable to all but the most dynamic of them, who then leave. Your and the Left’s desire to have America replicate their governance and social orders, IMHO, is not only impossible, but a fool’s errand that promises to destroy America. Please reread my 657pm and 846pm.
    DonB 1017pm – Deconstructing each other’s service to America, whether military or otherwise, does not lead anyone to greater understanding or move them from their calcified positions. But at least one out of four Americans want to destroy and fundamentally transform the America that half of us love. The Human Freedom Index for us is a measure of the progress of that destruction. Wouldn’t it be more profitable to urge the Left to explain the motives, means, and methods that give them hope for the new America they envision? Could we not learn more from that so as to oppose them more effectively in the minds of the undecideds and independents, than debating whose father did how much in some war or public service or …?

    Like

  37. Steve Frisch Avatar
    Steve Frisch

    I love the disclaimer that critiquing another’s service does not contribute to ‘greater understanding’ then following it with a statement like the one below.
    “But at least one out of four Americans want to destroy and fundamentally transform the America that half of us love.”
    What George is missing of course is that ‘America’ is not the one thing that he thinks it is; it is the sum total of the dreams hopes aspirations, sweat, blood, and hard work of millions of people, many of whom view the world through a lens that may not be the same as his, but who share the American dream.
    Some of those people believe that America stands for equal opportunity, for law and equality under the law, for freedom of faith, conscience and speech, for the right to pursue happiness (even what he may see as dysfunctional happiness like gay marriage).
    I personally would put free speech, free religion and freedom of assembly at the top of the list of American values even though I am not a religious person, because if one does not have freedom of conscience, other freedoms are less likely to be realized.
    But America is also a child of the Enlightenment, and many Americans like me believe that part of our core values are scientific and rational progress, enabling and safeguarding achievement and success, democracy with a small d, egalitarianism, and the special role that a democratic republic can play in forwarding the principles of liberty across the globe.
    These are American values too.
    Once, when Alexis de Tocqueville coined the term to describe America and before it was redefined by neoconservatives as global military hegemony, that was defined as “American Exceptionalism”.
    Stating that a quarter of America wants to destroy the values that 50% love is complete nonsense. There is no empirical data to back that up, surveys of Americans would show that about 90% of Americans share the vision I described above.
    But what it does show is that the entire intent of George’s blog is to sew discord amongst Americans whose values should bind us together and make every decision we make about an ideological struggle between right and left. This strategy, seized upon by conservatives to freeze governance and create the self fulfilling prophecy of a dysfunctional state, is exactly the type of anti-Americanism that leads me back to this blog to illuminate for the few critical readers who come here just how craven this strategy is.

    Like

  38. Steve Frisch Avatar
    Steve Frisch

    Don and Todd you are really now just looking like stupid bitter old men.
    For you to critique Paul’s service is utterly laughable. Paul served, as a member of the military he would have had to go where he was told, and he made the commitment to do so. That is apparently a far cry from what either of you (or I) did.

    Like

  39. Todd Juvinall Avatar
    Todd Juvinall

    Steve Frisch | 01 October 2015 at 09:41 AM
    As usual you don’t read or comprehend very well. I have always praised Paul’s service. You are a fat ass fool.

    Like

  40. Steve Frisch Avatar
    Steve Frisch

    Funny Todd I think of you as a stupid philandering oxycontin addled a**hole. So what?
    Looking back on this bog over the years I can find a number of times that you and Paul went a round or two over this issue. We can simply add liar to the list above.

    Like

  41. Todd Juvinall Avatar
    Todd Juvinall

    Steve Frisch | 01 October 2015 at 09:58 AM
    There you go again Frisch. You are starting the Jim Beam way early and you need to stop. There is help for your maladues you know. And really, what could have been done with all that tax money you swiped from your employees? Maybe the homeless would have a roof over their heads. You are too easy. What a hoot!

    Like

  42. George Rebane Avatar

    re SteveF’s 937am – the attentive reader will note that Mr Frisch comes at me with the now classical Alinsky attack – isolate your opponent as singular in his views, then insert the right words into his mouth to assault. The record in these pages shows the obverse of that – RR identifies their ideological opponent as a member of a larger group holding similar views, and then engages to oppose those views and how that cohort dispenses/disseminates them. But desperate times call for desperate means I suppose, and for socialism it has been a desperate time since the end of WW2.
    Mr Fisch’s cherry picked tenets are indeed accepted per se by an overwhelming majority of Americans. But I hold that he and his do not accept them as we witness in the daily press (e.g. Warren’s recent attack on Brookings Institute economist Robert Litan, who dared conclude that Warren’s prescriptions for new investment advisor regulations would diminish the number of consumers enjoying such services, got the man fired. And she did this under in most blatantly sleazy manner.) The Left’s first response is always to silence their critics, usually by the government gun. The legislation they have passed and sought is grim testimony to that – and they readily eat their own.
    But people of Mr Frisch’s ilk fly low and fast under the limited radar left to the gruberized. When their entire agenda is examined, it resembles more the nostrums of Marx and Lenin, than those of our Founders, Bastiat, Mises, Hayek, … . And yes, I do maintain that the core Left which according to Pew and other researchers is about 20-25% of Americans is antithetical to the about 50% Americans (not all core conservatives and libertarians) who nevertheless are akin to the Conservatarian principles espoused on RR and by MANY other voices across the land.
    Contrary to Mr Frisch’s cynical attempt to convince the unread that I am alone or in remote tributary of American political thought, I am not. Were I the lone howling wolf in the foothills that he likes to characterize, then he and his would pay no attention to the thoughts and observations of people like me. Yet their blatant perfidy is important to witness and comprehend if it is to be successfully opposed in the public forums.

    Like

  43. Stevenfrisch Avatar
    Stevenfrisch

    George I think you need to look up ‘cherry pick’. It’s not cherry picking if one takes a single sentence from a statement and it’s an accurate representation of the entire statement. It’s doubly not cherry picking if the author confirms that the sentence one pulls means exactly what they said it did, which you just confirmed.
    For one who critiques the innumerate you are displaying a level of illiteracy characteristic of Walt.
    We are all Americans unlike Bastiat, Hayek and Mises😎

    Like

  44. Stevenfrisch Avatar
    Stevenfrisch

    And when did I become responsible for the actions of Elizabeth Warren?

    Like

  45. Don Bessee Avatar
    Don Bessee

    Frisch I would direct your attention to the lefties and likely your views of GW Bushes Air Reserve service, kettle meet pot.

    Like

  46. George Rebane Avatar

    StevenF 1055am – My use of ‘cherry picked’ is correct since it clearly refers to your select tenets that do not represent the more revealing range of your ideology as you have made clear on RR, and by your professional activities and writings elsewhere. You are a dyed-in-wool and sincere collectivist who first and foremost sees a growing Leviathan (especially in the direction of Agenda21) as the salve for all social ills.
    And nowhere have you been accused “responsible” for Warren’s actions – that’s another of your not-so-subtle fabrications in these conversations. But you are accused of being in the nation’s ideological cohort of which she is a prominent thought and political leader. More likely she is responsible for your actions πŸ˜‰

    Like

Leave a comment