Rebane's Ruminations
November 2014
S M T W T F S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  

ARCHIVES


OUR LINKS


YubaNet
White House Blog
Watts Up With That?
The Union
Sierra Thread
RL “Bob” Crabb
Barry Pruett Blog

George Rebane

[This is the addended transcript to my regular KVMR commentary aired on 5 November 2014.]

As someone once said, elections have consequences.  And today this makes possible several different ways forward that can slow the surge toward socialism we have endured since Democrats took over Congress in 2006.  President Obama nailed it this year when he declared to both heartened conservatives and duck-and-cover liberals that this election was really a report card on Team Obama’s policies.  It would let voters assess everything that this administration and its congressional supporters have done to give America its ‘2% economy’, uncounted scandals, incompetent governance, international disdain, and partisan polarization, all rolled up in one package that many argue represents a new low point in the country’s history.

Nationally, the election was indeed a so-called Republican wave, both in Congress where the GOP will have historical majorities, and in the state houses.  Does that constitute a mandate?  Well yes.  Even liberal pundits this morning acknowledged that we now have a popular mandate to roll back regulatory overreach and reduce the size of government.  But that is not the way that the diehard Left is spinning the message sent by the people.  Led by Harry Reid and repeated in our local echo chambers, they claim that the real message from Americans is that government should now work together.  But that desperate interpretation fails on all accounts.


After obstructing literally all Congressional actions by blocking more than 350 House passed bills from the Senate floor, Dirty Harry now claims that Americans gave Congress to the Republicans so that they would work with Democrats to pass more laws to grow government, stifle economic growth, inject more regulations into all aspects of our lives, reduce the workforce, increase our unfunded liabilities and stultifying debt, and continue our retreat from global leadership – I don’t think so.

It is clear that Democrats, planning to elect another Clinton, will spend the next two years working hard to make President Obama and his six-year legacy a dim memory in the minds of voters.  Lady Macbeth’s ‘Out damn spot, out I say!’ now more than ever, will considerably exercise Hillary as she attempts to erase the record of her Obama years.  The Republicans in their turn will do their best to keep the pair joined at the hip, and hope that ol’ Joe Biden will become the Democrats’ standard bearer in 2016.

Locally, most of us celebrated the re-election of our congressmen Doug LaMalfa and Tom McClintock.  I hear that they plan to work together to stop Sacramento and Washington from further ruining NorCal’s economy, water resources, public land access, and the environment.

Here in Nevada County the big issue was Measure S, the voter initiative to replace the existing medical marijuana ordinance.  The pro-S people claimed that medical marijuana is in short supply, and that needy patients do not have adequate access to the weed.  The initiative failed because its proponents never made the case for such shortages, and argued strongly that voters didn’t need to hear more than a few heart-rending stories of people deprived of their medicines.  The reality is that 7 out of 10 county voters decided to keep the current ordinance, and that number indicates support across a broad demographic beyond the claimed old conservative fogies who were supposed to be the only anti-S contingent. I believe there is no doubt that both medical and recreational marijuana use will be legalized in its various forms across the country including California.  But we would be wise to hold back a bit, and watch other states with more lenient marijuana laws to see first what works and what doesn’t.

Finally, the Republicans will now have two years to attempt broadly accepted repairs to damage done to the country by Barack Obama and his uncritical progressive political allies.  But this will not be a free ride.  The GOP, along with its conservative contingent, needs to show the country that it can bring about constructive change in which Americans can again put their hopes.

My name is Rebane, and I also expand on this and related themes on georgerebane.com where an expanded transcript of this commentary and the discussion continues among readers with widely differing perspectives.  As always, my views are not necessarily shared by KVMR.  Thank you for listening.

[Addendum]  I’ll start this with an email from Nancy Garcia that was waiting for me when I got back from my recording session.  Nancy and husband Eddie (Eduard) Garcia have been active in Nevada County conservative circles.  The Garcias were in the founding activities of the NC Tea Party and State of Jefferson movements.  Nancy is a former president of the NCTP and Eddie chairs the current NC SoJ steering committee.  Nancy encouraged me to post her email.

George,

I just had to laugh when I scrolled down to your 5nov14 update on RR.  It was a delicious moment as the progressive's "talking points" were destroyed by the victories of Mia Love, Joni Ernst, Tim Scott and Elise Stefanik. 

Coming back down to earth, the real work begins now.  We have two short years to repair some of the damage from a six year train wreck. Our job will be to hold our elected official's feet to the fire.  And most importantly, may they remember – principles count!

Nancy Garcia=

I am told that many of our progressive pundits are frantically waving their purple flags today.  They got the color wrong.  What seems to blindside them is that voters voted their experiences of the last six years – no more BS about this administration, for its record of lies, incompetence, and overreach are all now a part of the public record.

Barack Obama is the most opaque president in our history, a politician so successfully buoyed by the lamestream that it has taken the electorate six years to discover and repudiate him.  What the voters have learned is that they unwittingly drank the kool-aid and returned to office an intellectual lightweight, inexperienced political hack, widely acknowledged socialist ideologue, and arrogant administrator with no executive experience (save having Valerie Jarrett’s contact info).  All of these attributes are now evident to everyone save Obama’s most ardent core constituency.  It is they who have always voted for him because of the color of his skin and not the content of his character.  Nothing here will change.

In a recent conversation with a left-of-center friend and colleague, the matter of money in politics and its ability to swing elections came up.  While my friend's tendency is to approach a solution that would restrict the use of money in election campaigns, predictably mine is to modify the election process so that money would not be able to play such a prominent role in deciding the winner.  In short, in a liberal society money is the prime enabler of free speech, and restricting its use abbreviates not only our rights, but also the benefits to society in the encouragement of productive activities for the benefit of all.

Over the years I have come to accept that the impact of campaign monies is directly proportional to the dumbth of the electorate.  In other words, the more uneducated, uninformed, and intellectually deprived is the voter, the more impact will moneyed repetition of simple messages have on such individuals.  And, of course, the other way around.  Think of it as a seesaw, the influence of money goes up as the smarts come down.  So what to do?

One solution that hits the hip-level processing hot button of progressives is to once more introduce the notion of minimum qualifications for voting.  We have to pass knowledge tests to qualify for society’s permissions in so many other domains of daily affairs, why not also include something beyond mirror-fogging for becoming a franchised voter.  I can hear the cacophony of the collectivists now, all screaming about the impossibility of fairly and equitably achieving such an end, and being ascribed a racist for even suggesting it.  Nothing could be further from the truth, since government and corporations already administer proof of skill/knowledge tests in so many areas before we’re allowed to do something or demonstrate certified expertise.

Such testing would involve the basics of civics – structure and operation of government, law, and the current state of the state.  The test details would be left to non-partisan commissions at various levels – federal, state, county/city.  The objectives of such testing would conform to those used by the DMV and the federal government for new citizens – in short, make the voting franchise as widely accessible as possible, and provide the ‘free’ educational resources to remediate those who have failed the test which can be taken as many times as necessary.  Such an initiative must, of course, be supported by constitutional amendments at both state and federal levels.

Bottom line – to keep dummies out of the voting booth while minimizing the gratuitous impact of money in elections, and its subsequent bad governance, require of the citizen a basic level of knowledge that activates and maintains his right as a franchised ‘Elector’.  I believe that the notion is at least worthy of considered and rational discussion.

Posted in , ,

75 responses to “Election 2014 – what it was and wasn’t”

  1. Todd Juvinall Avatar
    Todd Juvinall

    It looks like the dems ave swiped the San Diego race.

    Like

  2. George Rebane Avatar

    drivebyposter 656am – Good piece; it floats a lot of questions.

    Like

  3. Bill Tozer Avatar
    Bill Tozer

    My, my, the turd polishing continues.and is gaining steam.
    First from 1600 Pennsylvania, our President speaks. Shellacking, what shellacking? He did not hear the voters. He heard the 2/3 of those that did not vote loud and clear and is listening to them. Nothing to see here, much ado about nothing.
    Second, Botox Nancy blames it all on low over turnout. That is true because mid-terms historically have lower voter turnout than the Big One, aka, the Presidential race. To really shine up the turd, the Botox Queen stated that the Dems drew over a million more voters than the R’s, just not in the right districts, proof that the voters preferred the Democratic Party and their message.
    Third, for our local county folks, there is a bright star in the Eastern Sky. Go east, young man, whence cometh your salvation. Truckee is purple, which means they liked Heidi and Co. Tom only drew 47% of the vote in the Eastern Sky, more proof that Truckee is purple. In fact, anything that favors the left is purple and anything that favors Tom and company is extreme. Even Ms. Smith put her hopes on the Eastern Star to shine brightly on her countenance and whence her salvation cometh.
    Turd polishing at its finest.

    Like

  4. Todd Juvinall Avatar
    Todd Juvinall

    “Turd polishing”! You have me laughing my arse off BillT!

    Like

  5. George Rebane Avatar

    BillT 846am – Good of you to point out again the hubris of the progressive elites re the non-voting public. Their silence is immediately co-opted and gathered under the mythical mandate of the Left with Obama’s pronouncement in effect that ‘We know what they are thinking, what they want, and what they need.’ And having declared that as his latest Received Truth, he will now proceed to deliver.

    Like

  6. Ben Emery Avatar
    Ben Emery

    Bill,
    Nancy Pelosi is correct voter turnout sucked and it cost them the election.
    The question is why was voter turnout so low?
    1) We have two parties that don’t represent average people so those people don’t feel like their vote counts and don’t participate.
    2) Republicans have made voting harder and harder for Americans and the Democrats use the issue as a wedge get out the vote issue and failed
    3) The Biggest factor in the 2014 mid term elections is the Democratic Party is lost and has no soul left. The Republican Party is literally insane and insane is preferable to the participating American voter than what the Democrats have to offer.
    I spend most of my time on FB debating party line Democrats about how horrible the party has become and then I come over here to Rebanes and am called a Democratic supporter, too funny.

    Like

  7. Scott Obermuller Avatar

    “Republicans have made voting harder and harder for Americans”
    Proof?
    “The Republican Party is literally insane”
    Literally?
    “the Democratic Party is lost and has no soul left.”
    What would you suggest – even more of what pissed off the American voters on Tuesday?

    Like

  8. Keen Observer Avatar
    Keen Observer

    Ben’s last post came close to actually addressing the problem of low voter turnout. As a adult, I am fully aware of the broken nature of our democratic system, which at best is an illusion of actually representing the people.
    Let’s have some common sense here through an analogy…a dog knows well the relationship it has to its “master”, and thus gives the proper loyalty accordingly to ensure survival. The Democratic Party has carefully developed this scenario to develop a larger voter base, mainly through welfare benefits and hollow promises of better futures for all. What I can’t seem to understand is how Republicans can recognize this Democratic Party tactic, but fail to see this same relationship develop between Politicians (of all stripes) and their generous political donors. When an enriched person donates huge sums of money to politicans, who then is the “master” in that scenario? Wouldn’t the viewpoints of the donation-receiving politician become heavily skewed towards the “hand that feeds?”
    Most posters on here (myself included) have chastised grant seekers for accepting money to promote another’s agenda. But this same situation occurs extensively in both political parties, yet not a peep from Dr. Rebane on the inherent and immoral relationship created by the money injected into the political arena. Whether Republican or Democrat, if you go to bed at night feeling that any politician represents you more so than the ones writing the checks (Wall St., Unions, Corporations, etc.) to PAC campaigns, then you are truly the epitome of the “uninformed” voter.
    Drive By Poster, excellent reference to the Rolling Stone piece. Perhaps we could factor the rapacious and immoral greed practiced by Wall St. into Dr. Rebane’s argument for even more laissez-faire capitalism. After all, this greed worked out well for “everybody” in 1929, 2000, and 2007, didn’t it?

    Like

  9. Todd Juvinall Avatar

    Ben Emery 1:23 PM
    He says
    “3) The Biggest factor in the 2014 mid term elections is the Democratic Party is lost and has no soul left”
    Yes Ben, you finally have it right! I could not agree more. The left has driven their own souls right out of their own bodies! We on the right turned out enough people to boot the democrats sorry asses out of power. Now on to 2016 and a new Publican/Conservative President. You should get on board and help.
    The turnout in Pelosi’s own district was pretty crappy. Now how does she explain that? I thought those democrats in SF loved her. Why would they diss her? My goodness.
    There are what 750,000 people in each district? And 450,000 eligible voters? Well Pelosi’s District 12 turnout was about 152,000 people and her area is tiny. Most of those people live in a few square miles. They don’t have to travel a few blocks to vote. LAMalfa’s district, ours, had about 156,000 votes. It has a huge geographic area. How many counties? And this District turned out more voters. So you can quote Pelosi all you want but the facts are the facts. She had less and her registration edge is something like 4 to one democrat.

    Like

  10. George Rebane Avatar

    KeenO 221pm – Not sure you have applied those keen observation skills to RR. Be that as it may, since it costs money to exercise the First Amendment in any conceivable mode today, how would you allow/restrict its use when speaking about social issues and candidates for office?

    Like

  11. Scott Obermuller Avatar

    Keen Observer – what a joke! All politicians are on the take. All of Wall Street is evil. And all negroes are…..??? That’s called prejudice. I’m against greed, but I call it out no matter where it resides. Millions of Americans are greedy and poor, but they are still greedy. Why not call them out? How about middle class greed? Stupid greedy middle class idiots in the late twenties bought stock on margins that would make your head spin. Stupid greedy middle class morons dumped their IRAs into get rich quick nonsense in 2007 for over priced junk. Then boohooed until Uncle Sugar bailed them out. Let’s blame everyone who is greedy or blame no one. You are intellectually lazy. If you don’t like money ‘injected’ into the political arena, please describe your alternative. Please let us in on how this will work.

    Like

  12. Ben Emery Avatar
    Ben Emery

    Scott,
    Yes, literally! Everywhere around the planet people cannot believe that the Republican Party is a major party or even real. What makes them even more confused is that people actually vote for them. I have connections to people all over the world and it is just about universal opinion when it comes to the Republican Party.
    You were probably to busy celebrating the new era of Republican rule for the next generation and the outright rejection of liberal politics in the US after the 2004 election and forget this extremely popular international headline on the American electorate that voted for Republican George W Bush.
    “How can 59,054,087 people be so DUMB?”
    Voter ID’s makes it harder to vote, there is your proof. A dozen states or so have new laws making it harder to vote. What a surprise they are mostly swing states that have Republican legislatures.

    Like

  13. Scott Obermuller Avatar

    I see that Ben believes that reality is determined by democratic vote. The world is flat! Most folks did in fact think it so at one time. Ben believes it made it so.
    Belief is reality! I was too busy celebrating? Obviously Ben can’t understand the English language. You need to actually read my posts, Ben.
    “Voter IDs makes it harder to vote, there is your proof”
    Yep – reaching into your wallet and pulling out your ID is really hard for you Ben.
    I wasn’t aware that those on the left had that a hard a time at simple tasks. Are you proud of your lack of ability? Do you think that non whites are that imbecile?
    I have a 5 year old grandson that can reach into his pocket and pull out an ID card.
    Maybe he can help you. Believe it or not, Ben – in states with voter ID laws non whites voted in higher numbers after the voter ID laws were in place. They can do things you couldn’t imagine.

    Like

  14. Bill Tozer Avatar
    Bill Tozer

    A dozen or so states have new laws making it harder for non citizens to vote, and even harder for out of state residents to be bussed in to vote by union thugs and ruffians.
    It’s not fair! They want me to show ID to board a big ole jetliner and some racist merchant in Nevada City asked to see my ID when I tried to write a check.
    Ben looks at people of color as some inferior class of people who cannot do simple tasks such as put a stamp on an envelop or even seek and obtain a State Issued ID, or gasp!, a drivers license. Maybe they need Ben’s help with what to put in their grocery cart. It’s all because of 70,376,013.376 years of racism.
    Of course, I do not ever expect my Brother Ben to ever see that his thought processes are blatantly and inherently racist in and of itself. Never. The current problems in the Black Community can be traced back to The Great Society and the government’s unintended (I hope) consequences of breaking up society’s core structure, the family unit. Yes, my Brother, there were other problems in the people of color’s communities before The Great Society, but none so devastating. Yet, with all the history and problems, voting is not a difficult nor strenuous task for any citizen of the United States. Unless, you do not consider people of color your equals. Are they helpless, Ben, or just dumb as a bucket of rocks? Heck, getting up in the morning is sometimes difficult for all of us of every race, creed, and station in life. Go Mia Love, go! Go Senator Scott, go!

    Like

  15. fish Avatar
    fish

    Ben Emery
    Scott,
    Yes, literally! Everywhere around the planet people cannot believe that the Republican Party is a major party or even real. What makes them even more confused is that people actually vote for them. I have connections to people all over the world and it is just about universal opinion when it comes to the Republican Party.

    It’s a variation on “Pauline Kael” syndrome Scott. She didn’t know anyone who could possibly disagree with the left either!

    Like

  16. Walt Avatar

    Get a clue Ben, The people got a good taste of Progressive Socialism (again) and have spit it out. Just like a good swig of sour milk 5 days past the expiration date.
    Central planning fails every time. Just ask East Germany how that worked out.
    .
    As for ID to vote, SCOTUS has even gave their blessing. Welcome to the United States.
    Good ol’ “trust but verify” Except for states like Ca. where illegals get a drivers licence and an application to vote at the same time. Forget motorvoter? Think DMV cares?

    Like

  17. George Rebane Avatar

    BenE 722pm – Dear Ben, you simply have to expand your reading horizons to outlets like The Economist, WSJ, Der Welt, Le Monde, NYT, … . Those conclusions can only be sustained by limiting your purview to outlets like MSNBC, truthout.com, New Republic, and The Nation.

    Like

  18. Bill Tozer Avatar
    Bill Tozer

    Hello. Submitted for your consideration is th most bone chiling opinion I have read all year. Warning, it may keep you up at night.
    http://www.examiner.com/article/charles-hurt-remainder-of-obama-s-term-most-dangerous-two-years-150-years

    Like

  19. fish Avatar
    fish

    Warning, it may keep you up at night.
    So what….everything keeps me up at night……stupid dogs…..cop cars racing by…..idiot neighbors! Everything!

    Like

  20. Bill Tozer Avatar
    Bill Tozer

    Coffee keeps me up at night. Not the coffee per se, it’s the getting up to drain the bladder that keeps me up. You sound grumpy. Need a hug? Ok, I hear ya. I will slink away and go sit on a happy face…or…better yet, I will open up a can of worms for breakfast.

    Like

  21. fish Avatar
    fish

    <i…..it’s the getting up to drain the bladder that keeps me up.
    Yep….forgot to include this one!

    Like

  22. Walt Avatar

    Yes you did… what is “this one”????

    Like

  23. Bill Tozer Avatar
    Bill Tozer

    Walt, He forgot. 🙂

    Like

  24. fish Avatar
    fish

    Sorry Walt….should has posted the “phrase that pays”.
    …..it’s the getting up to drain the bladder that keeps me up.

    Like

  25. fish Avatar
    fish

    ….should has…..
    ….should have.
    May the inventor of auto correct suffer for all eternity!

    Like

Leave a comment