Rebane's Ruminations
October 2014
S M T W T F S
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031  

ARCHIVES


OUR LINKS


YubaNet
White House Blog
Watts Up With That?
The Union
Sierra Thread
RL “Bob” Crabb
Barry Pruett Blog

George Rebane

In 31oct14 WSJ article of the same name Kate Bachelder lists and expands on the ten high ranking pre-evidential and counter-evidential beliefs that our progressive cadres have accepted as revealed truth.  They have done this with an intensity and a 'reasonable basis' equal to that of the most devout fundamental Christians whom they deplore.  Ms Bachelder reminds us again that – “A hallmark of progressive politics is the ability to hold fervent beliefs, in defiance of evidence, that explain how the world works—and why liberal solutions must be adopted.”

Regular readers will recognize that all of these items have been extensively covered and debated in these pages.  I think that seeing these ten (there are, of course, more) in one place is useful as we go to the polls next Tuesday.  The bases for these beliefs being called superstitions are also summarized in the article (here).

1.     Spending more money improves education.

2.     Government spending stimulates the economy.

3.     Republican candidates always have a big spending advantage over Democrats.

4.     Raising the minimum wage helps the poor.

5.     Global warming is causing increasingly violent weather.

6.     Genetically modified food is dangerous.

7.     Voter ID laws suppress minority turnout.

8.     ObamaCare is gaining popularity.

9.     The Keystone XL pipeline would increase oil spills.

10.    Women are paid 77 cents on the dollar compared with men.

Posted in , ,

24 responses to “‘The Top 10 Liberal Supersitions’”

  1. fish Avatar
    fish

    Ah…a discussion of religion.
    This should make for an interesting weekend!

    Like

  2. Walt Avatar

    According to Charley Wrangle, The South won the civil war.
    ” Some of them believe that slavery isn’t over and they and think they won the Civil War!”
    Read more: http://www.businessinsider.com/charlie-rangel-some-republicans-believe-that-slavery-isnt-over-2014-10#ixzz3HkAYbtjY
    Any person of color who sides with the Right gets branded an ” Uncial Tom” ( yes man to the plantation owners, and usually the one with the whip in his hand.)
    You can add ” LIBS say Repubs are the party of the KKK”
    The last I checked the “stars and bars” isn’t the national flag.I guess LIB revisionism of history continues.
    What will be next? Abe Lincoln was a closet Democrat?

    Like

  3. Walt Avatar

    Found a good post in that story,, and just about sums it up.
    ” Slavery went from private ownership, to government ownership”
    ( That would be welfare checks to Obamaphones)

    Like

  4. Gregory Avatar
    Gregory

    I think the author needs a bit of revision, as Commandment the First is a bit off. The Holy Scriptures doesn’t read
    “Spending more money improves education”
    It actually says:
    “Bad educational outcomes are always due to not enough money being spent”.
    Corollaries are:
    “Bad educational outcomes is never due to inadequate or ineffective teachers”
    and,
    “To the extent there are bad teachers, they would perform adequately if the pay was higher or they had more training”.
    They are all variants of Fudd’s First Law of Opposition: “If you push something hard enough it will fall over”.
    If Gregory the First was Dictator-for-Life, he would decree that no teacher be hired or retained who can’t score at least a 1000 M+V (the average for college bound students) on the SAT, and when faced with a hue and cry, soften that a bit to a 950 and give existing teachers 5 years to get it up, to appear to have a heart towards teachers with below average academic prowess.
    Every child in every K-12 classroom deserves a teacher who has a clue what it takes to be ready for college by the time one graduates from high school.

    Like

  5. Gregory Avatar
    Gregory

    I hate my 20-20 grammatical hindsight. I can find my errors (some of which creep in with cut and paste, some of which are just boneheaded) 99.99% of the time only after I see them outside the edit box.

    Like

  6. George Rebane Avatar

    Gregory 150pm – I’ll go along with your expansion, and offer that it fell victim to the editor’s penchant for an acceptable abbreviation in Bachelder’s piece.

    Like

  7. Russ Steele Avatar

    Gregory@01:56
    Yea, that happens to me a lot too. Once posted the errors are very evident, but not in the edit box. Preview helps catch some but not all. Be as it may.

    Like

  8. Bill Tozer Avatar
    Bill Tozer

    Mr. Gregory, you will give them 5 years to get up to average? Hogwash. 5 years time of doing what the subpar is going to our kids is out and out bloody criminal. Thousands if not millions of pupils would have their bright futures severely diminished, their education ruined, and any chance of skipping down the road of destiny derailed. One can do much irreversible damage in 5 years. If you really cared about our education system and the future of our country, you would show subpar educators with diminished mental capacity the door right in the middle of class and strongly recommend they find a profession that does not involved destroying our young children’s lives.
    5 years? How about a week, max. Otherwise the young bright eyed and bushy tailed students will end up as just another crop of subpar teachers with subpar knowledge doing a subpar job. Sure, some will rise to the level of mediocrity, if fortunate.
    We owe the next generation that much and I, for one, would not wish the scenario laid out above with that kind of future on anyone’s child.
    For the historical record, there is a direct correlation between more inflation adjusted dollars spent on public education and declining test scores and student achievement. The more inflation adjusted dollars thrown at the unspeakable K-12 disaster, the more the scores drop. If you want the students’ achievement levels to drop like a rock even deeper into the bottom of the outhouse, just back up a dump truck of money to the problem and bury it with cash. Garage in, garbage out. Hmmm. A week may be to long.

    Like

  9. Bill Tozer Avatar
    Bill Tozer

    Nothing to do with education dollars, but the timing is sweet. Still, nobody is talking about our kids, just yapping about filing the war chests.
    http://www.nytimes.com/2014/11/01/us/california-race-brings-democrats-divide-on-education-into-focus.html

    Like

  10. Michael R. Kesti Avatar
    Michael R. Kesti

    Gregory 01:56 PM and Russ Steele 02:47 PM
    The solution to your edit-box-blindness is to use your word processor (with spelling and grammar correction enabled) rather than composing comments in the edit box. It’s a simple matter to copy from the word processor and paste to the edit box once you’re satisfied with your work.

    Like

  11. Gregory Avatar
    Gregory

    MRK, I can’t be bothered, that’s an obvious solution similar to what I gave up on about 30 years ago when I was on an ARPAnet node. You’ll just have to suffer my typos.
    Tozer, once again, you’re missing the obvious… there’s no bloody way anyone is going to fire half the teacher corps.

    Like

  12. Bill Tozer Avatar
    Bill Tozer

    Well, Mr. Gregory, it ain’t going to bloody happen. However, if William the Great or William the Conquerer or William of Orange, or William the First was made dictator for life, a few heads would roll and the kids could use the heads as soccer balls.
    If we just axed the bottom 5% of the teachers based on some provable metric (just the bottom 5% of lousy performers), then the overall test scores and student performance would rise. Like magic. Like removing a cyst and the whole body feels better.

    Like

  13. Bill Tozer Avatar
    Bill Tozer

    Concerning item # 8, the young adults are coming and boy they are not happy.
    http://www.huffingtonpost.com/brad-chase/millennials-openly-defy-t_b_6080052.html?ncid=txtlnkusaolp00000592

    Like

  14. Bill Tozer Avatar
    Bill Tozer

    0bamacare is gaining in popularity. Yes!, if you read the White House “unbiased” poll. Others disagree, but it might be gaining in popularity. Might even rise to unpopular from quite unpopular.
    http://www.realclearpolitics.com/epolls/other/obama_and_democrats_health_care_plan-1130.html

    Like

  15. Michael R. Kesti Avatar
    Michael R. Kesti

    Gregory 01Nov14 12:29 AM
    So, you hate your “20-20 grammatical hindsight” but cannot be bothered to use a tool that might eliminate that hindsight’s occurrence.
    There are none so lame as those who will not walk.

    Like

  16. Bill Tozer Avatar
    Bill Tozer

    Item 3, far right wing extremist fringe money outspends Dems. Here is a Dem who decries outside money and peddling in local affairs, local politics, and local elections. Reminds me of The Brother Ben mantra. Evil NRA has donated 900 dollars to the cause. Yes, Bloomberg money welcomed in local politics and local elections by one Western State Dem.
    http://www.examiner.com/article/embattled-gun-hating-colorado-senator-begs-for-out-of-state-money-condemns-it
    Don’t ya just hate that one man, one vote thang? The people are speaking up and more lib money needed, ASAP.

    Like

  17. Gregory Avatar
    Gregory

    Kesti, it would seem that in the spectrum of hate, the intensity of my hate of 20-20 typo hindsight is not what it could be.
    No, it isn’t worth the added time to always do edits in another app and then copy, as most of the time I’m perfectly happy with the results without the fire drill.

    Like

  18. Keen Observer Avatar
    Keen Observer

    Dr. Rebane,
    For the sake of conversation, I would like to address your points of the “Liberal Credo”. Please note that I use the word “correct” to agree with your inclusion of the talking point, and not my personal agreement.
    1) This is indeed correct, but this logic also applies to just about every facet of government. Every liberal holds dear that the correct size of government supplied with robust funding is the true secret to solving any and all of society’s ills.
    2) Government spending can stimulate the economy, but not in the liberal sense of welfare benefits and/or widespread meager stimulus payments. Eisenhower proved that intelligent government investments into infrastructure and key educational areas (subsidized STEM degrees) can most certainly raise the QOL bar for those willing to in turn invest themselves into bettering their future. However, Eisenhower had the advantage of a higher corporate tax rate in a pre-globalization corporate environment, but that is a topic for another conversation.
    Also, FHA loans provide an opportunity for those on the lower rungs of the socioeconomic ladder to increase their net wealth through home ownership, this wealth is mostly passed on to future offspring. This will progressively raise the QOL from generation to generation, if the macroeconomic environment remains consistent.
    In summary, intelligent government spending can both indirectly and directly stimulate the economy, but this would need to be applied in a “teach a man to fish” format, rather than the liberal “give a man a fish” format.
    3) Correct
    4) Correct
    5) Correct
    6) George, given that you are a man of science, I am surprised that you choose to subscribe to the belief that GMO’s have no ill effects on human health. From a supply standpoint, GMOS are the best thing since sliced bread. But the mass uniformity of the food supply allows room for weakness, a single calamity or plant virus could decimate a huge percentage of the food supply.
    Also, like most things in science these days, the financial backing of the scientific process has an uncanny effect on the end results from said studies. However, unlike the pro-AGW crowd, the anti-GMO crowd has not much to gain financially from tackling the GMO machine. This seems to me to mirror the positive scientific opinion of tobacco smoking in the 50’s (remember, it was a great weight loss solution back then). Time will tell if GMOs have long-term negative effects, but I would encourage you to look into the scientific studies done on GMOs in India. Also, bear in mind that even the dictator Putin has banned many GMO based products in Russia, that fact alone should make one wonder.
    7) Correct
    8) Correct
    9) Correct, but given the previous track record of poor oversight on pipeline maintenance, this could be an issue down the road. As it stands currently, fines for improper pipeline maintenance pale in comparison when compared to the cost of actually bringing the pipeline up to code. Until the inverse of this situation occurs, one can only assume that for the sake of monetary efficiency, corporations will not invest resources into pipeline maintenance, and fines will continue to be viewed as “the cost of doing business.”
    10) Mostly correct, its actually more like 90-99 cents on the dollar, depending on the industry. “77 cents on the dollar” makes for a great campaign launch point though.

    Like

  19. George Rebane Avatar

    KeenO 1058am – Thank you for that thoughtful comment. Recall that the list of ten is from the article, and it’s reason for being included in my post is to remind some of our Left-leaners that such notions are not mine alone (I am perennially honored by them for being the lone progenitor of and believer in such notions).
    Re GMOs – what you say is correct – uniformity in stasis is definitely a danger to a malady such as you describe. It is not clear (at least from my readings) that such uniformity is the necessary result of genetically modifying a plant. In other words, nature takes over and new mutations begin to accrue which give the plant resistance as time goes on while, perhaps, weakening its fecundity and designed resistance to targeted pests.
    Re pipeline problems – I am not aware of any catastrophic after effects of pipeline accidents. As BP’s gulf oil spill again showed those who would but look, crude oil is a natural material that has been upwelling into the oceans for eons with no bad effects, natural bacteria will just reduce it into benign (undetectable) byproducts. A little noted (by econuts) case history are the beaches and Pacific waters of southern California (especially in the LA area) prior to extensive oil production in the LA basin. The subterranean oil pressure was so high that the beaches were filled with globs of raw crude, and so were the waters with oil slicks. We all went to the beach in the 1950s and always packed rubbing alcohol in the bag to take the oil off our feet and hands before going home. It was just part of the drill, and no one looked at it as if it were some kind of harmful pollution. Tougher people, better times.

    Like

  20. Gregory Avatar
    Gregory

    For a better sense of how far modern liberalism has fallen from its roots, here is the 10 Commandments of Liberalism from Bertrand Russel, as penned in 1951 (in the New York Times, no less):
    Do not feel absolutely certain of anything.
    Do not think it worth while to proceed by concealing evidence, for the evidence is sure to come to light.
    Never try to discourage thinking for you are sure to succeed.
    When you meet with opposition, even if it should be from your husband or your children, endeavor to overcome it by argument and not by authority, for a victory dependent upon authority is unreal and illusory.
    Have no respect for the authority of others, for there are always contrary authorities to be found.
    Do not use power to suppress opinions you think pernicious, for if you do the opinions will suppress you.
    Do not fear to be eccentric in opinion, for every opinion now accepted was once eccentric.
    Find more pleasure in intelligent dissent than in passive agreement, for, if you value intelligence as you should, the former implies a deeper agreement than the latter.
    Be scrupulously truthful, even if the truth is inconvenient, for it is more inconvenient when you try to conceal it.
    Do not feel envious of the happiness of those who live in a fool’s paradise, for only a fool will think that it is happiness.
    This was recently quoted by climate heretic Dr.Judith Curry as a statement on how illiberal modern climate science has become. Food for thought.

    Like

  21. fish Avatar
    fish

    Posted by: Gregory | 02 November 2014 at 07:59 AM
    Like everything progressive infest…..it all turns to shit!
    Liberal used to be us! GamerGate anyone?

    Like

  22. Gregory Avatar
    Gregory

    Fish, I never stopped calling myself liberal, quietly, though I never accepted Bertrand Russel as my personal political savior, looking more to the likes of John Locke and that famous founder of the Democratic-Republican Party, Thomas Jefferson. Not to mention Karl Popper, a philosopher primarily of science (one modern application is that you can’t “prove” catastrophic global warming to be true while you can falsify it) but also planted in me the idea that the best design for a government is not one that has the best outcome when the right person is in the right job but rather when the wrong person in that job can do less damage.
    By Russell’s Commandments, the Obama administration may well be the most illiberal since the 1800’s.

    Like

  23. Bill Tozer Avatar
    Bill Tozer

    Back to item number 8. The Patient Protection and blah blah blah Act. Patient protection? Why should I pay a monthly premium and still face a $6,000.00 deductible? Subsidies only help with the monthly nut, not the immoral deductible. Shoot howdy, $5,999.99 out of pocket on top of monthly premiums before health insurance kicks in? No thanks, I’ll use toilet paper instead.
    http://finance.yahoo.com/news/obamacare-could-face-large-numbers-101500195.html

    Like

  24. Bill Tozer Avatar
    Bill Tozer

    And the hits just keep on coming. Number 8 on the Top Ten playlist is a little number by Queen Nancy and the Royal Wall Climbers:
    http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2014/11/03/some-obamacare-patients-with-high-deductibles-turning-to-community-care-centers/

    Like

Leave a comment