Rebane's Ruminations
April 2013
S M T W T F S
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
282930  

ARCHIVES


OUR LINKS


YubaNet
White House Blog
Watts Up With That?
The Union
Sierra Thread
RL “Bob” Crabb
Barry Pruett Blog

George Rebane

The tragic terrorist bomb blasts at the Boston Marathon have been more than adequately acknowledged; I can add little of substance to the reports and sentiments.

However, I do want to express some considerable irritation at how the entire affair was covered by the media, especially Fox News, in the immediate aftermath of the incident.  For two hours following, the coverage was one of repetition, tedium, paternalizing, and generally pabulum for an audience considered to be a notch above the kiddies who used to watch Mr Rogers’ Neighborhood.

And this type of coverage has become the de rigueur of such ‘real time’ broadcast reportage over the years.  Everyone available who could be hauled in front of a mike was given more than adequate time to repeat the same banalities and tautologies – hailing the first responders as “heroes”, opining how ‘terrible’, ‘cowardly’ and ‘senseless’ the act was, that the investigators will leave no rock unturned, assuring everyone that the perps will be brought to justice under the full extent of the law, …, and last but definitely the very least, not wanting to speculate on what happened “until we know all the facts”.  Bullshit.

Even the President, three hours after the concurrent explosions that dispersed ball bearings and other sharp metal objects through their victims, was not willing to step out there and conclude that this was an act of terror on the American homeland perpetrated by one or more sophisticated terrorists.  What the hell did he think happened?  that someone’s lunch blew up?  Then after high school sophomores in Des Moines knew it was an act of terror and not wanting a repeat of their Benghazi response, it became so embarrassing for the White House that they stepped out and called it an act of terror.

So, instead of wasting viewers’ time with inanities after such an event, here’s what the media outlets should do.  When they talk to one of their VIP guests or on-the-scene witnesses, ask them to speculate, to conjure up what they think might have happened, or who did it, or what caused it, or whatever.  Establish a ‘Speculation Segment’ for this kind of expression, put up a frame around the video that identifies it as such and tells everyone that this person is just responding to the media’s request to speculate.  Part of the ground rules of responding during such a ‘Speculation Segment’ is that whatever you say there, it will not be held against you as subsequent evidence becomes available.

Hell, the rest of us in the country are speculating our fannies off as we watch the same video segments played over and over again, and guest after guest blabbers the same inconsequentials.  We’re speculating, so let them also speculate while new facts develop, and make the program interesting as a senator, or former mayor, or DHS official, or the neighborhood mail carrier gives their take on what they know to that moment in time.  We in the audience are smart enough to know that they’re doing nothing more than what we are doing, but it would be interesting to hear someone else put together what appears to be a plausible explanation for what may have happened.  Tell us your hunches, please!  And you'll get a ‘King’s X’ because you did it during the ‘Speculation Segment’.

(BTW, the bombings were definitely not ‘cowardly’ or ‘senseless’.  They were purposeful, carefully thought out, and took considerable courage to successfully penetrate the nationwide security system against terror that we have had in place since 9/11.  If you think otherwise then, inspired by your deeply held credo, go try to pull off the same thing at a public event in Teheran or Pyongyang.)

Posted in

80 responses to “On inanities after the Boston bombings”

  1. Bill Tozer Avatar
    Bill Tozer

    The news is so sad. I don’t know why I even bother anymore to find out what is happening in America or the world. Yesterday Lumpy of Leave It To Beaver fame has passed on. My heart is full of grief today. It puts things in perspective.

    Like

  2. Ben Emery Avatar
    Ben Emery

    Terrorism – Noun
    The use of violence and intimidation in the pursuit of political aims.
    Kissinger relationship with known terrorist
    http://www.tabletmag.com/jewish-news-and-politics/129086/wikileaks-insight-into-arafat
    US Drone Warfare killing/ terrorizing innocent civilians
    http://www.cnn.com/2013/03/15/world/asia/u-n-drone-objections
    Preemptive invasion of Iraq
    Coup de’tat of who knows how many democratic elected leaders
    Iran 1953 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iaGCJmCAJ40
    I would be careful throwing around the term terrorists.

    Like

  3. George Rebane Avatar

    BenE 626pm – That definition is more than a bit wanting because so many other acts will also satisfy it. And one can cause terror with no act of violence per se, but just anticipation of it in the victim.
    And who do you admonish with your “careful” remark?

    Like

  4. Ben Emery Avatar
    Ben Emery

    “And who do you admonish with your “careful” remark?”
    To all of us.

    Like

  5. Barry Pruett Avatar

    Just heard a great point. How many law abiding citizens in Boston are sitting on their couch right now with a shotgun, pistol, or sport rifle, wating for a Chechen on the run to break through their door?

    Like

  6. George Rebane Avatar

    BarryP 726am – Yes, the Chechen would have less to fear in breaking into someone’s house if the population were to be disarmed. Don’t Chechens have rights too?

    Like

  7. Gregory Avatar

    George, with the strong restrictions on arms in the Boston area, I’m not sure how many folks hunkering down are doing so with a gun handy.
    “It’s likely in my view to be a McVeigh- Unabomber type with undetermined motivation.” – Paul E.
    Nice try, Paul.
    Here’s a nice picture of police in Mass. with what I assume are real, fully automatic M-16’s and 30 round magazines:
    http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2013-04-19/the-boston-terror-will-benefit-the-nra-hurt-gun-control
    And here I thought they were only good for killing lots of people in a short amount of time.
    Bloomberg Businessweek thinks the events will help the NRA’s cause and I suspect the NRA would be happy for that to be true.

    Like

  8. Gregory Avatar

    “I would be careful throwing around the term terrorists.” – Ben
    Yet another inanity after the Boston bombings.

    Like

  9. Bill Tozer Avatar
    Bill Tozer

    Yep, talk about Chicken Kiev.
    This term terrorist gets tossed about lately and watered down in some cases and avoided in other cases. I don’t have to pull out the Ole Websters to know what it means.
    The Fort Hood shooter fires at unarmed soldiers shouting loudly “God is Great” and it is called workplace violence.
    Catholics and Evangelicals are labeled potential terrorists by our Military Intelligence.
    Timothy McVay was driven purely by political motives. He targeted a government building and his stated reason was revenge for Wacko. He also stated that he was unaware of any day care in the building at the time.
    To me a terrorist is one who intentionally makes civilians as the target. Like the Boston Massacre II or the World Trade Center, parts one and two. Or the Times Square plot, etc.
    This is not to say there is not collateral damage inflicted upon innocent civilians when government facilities and enemies are targeted. The humorous veiled inferences that the Tea Party (or a right wing disgruntled extremist group) was behind this attack on civilians wearing running shorts with little protection is plum crazy. If the Tea Party types were involved, their target would have been government buildings, not runners and their families and friends.
    The Middle East is full of folks who purposely target unarmed innocents. They even attack mosque worshipers if they cannot control the mosque. That is real terrorism.
    Timothy McVay and the abortion clinic bomber did reprehensible deeds and the left constantly points to them when the term terrorist comes up and overlook the vast majority of other terrorists and are strangely reluctant to label them as such.
    This whole current atmosphere has eerily echos The Underground Weathermen of the 60’s. Many similarities going on as the general populace feels that our Constitution Rights are being threaten, and that threat may be real. Chicken Kiev.

    Like

  10. Russ Steele Avatar

    New York governor Andrew Cuomo connects Boston bombing to climate change.
    “It’s a terrible situation in Boston. And, unfortunately, … one gets the sense that this is more reflective of the ‘new normal,’ if you will,” he explained. “So much of society is changing so rapidly. We talk about a ‘new normal’ when it comes to climate change and adjusting to a change in the weather patterns. ‘New normal’ when it comes to public security in a post-9/11 world. Where these random acts of violence, which at one time were implausible, now seem all-too-frequent.
    Talk about stupid. Only a brain dead liberal could believe that climate change was what forced these terrorist to attend an Islamic terrorist training camp to learn how to make pressure cooker bombs.

    Like

  11. George Rebane Avatar

    RussS 1043am – where did you hear that they attended an Islamic terrorist camp?

    Like

  12. Douglas Keachie Avatar
    Douglas Keachie

    Bet a cookie he’s in the sewer system or in the river.

    Like

  13. Bill Tozer Avatar
    Bill Tozer

    Russ, it appears the Boston Bombers were of the Caucasian race. Only thing that is important to the MSM. Can’t be any religious views, now can it? Can’t have anything to do with our immigration policy now can it? It has everything to do with the color of his skin from the liberal prism. Wonder what Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. would have to say about our media.

    Like

  14. Gregory Avatar

    George, it was probably an Islamist edX MOOC terrorist camp.
    BTW, there was a ghost who recently claimed he’d not return to haunt us unless he was politely invited back… you didn’t, did you?

    Like

  15. Russ Steele Avatar

    George@11:09AM
    The older brother was more radicalized than the younger brother and was out of the country for six months, I am suggesting that he was in a training camp. Stratfor suggested that he may have received some training abroad, but could have just learned how to make IES from al Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula’s Inspire Magazine. The brothers are reported to have used explosive vests and the older brother may have blown himself up. Did they make these explosive vests on their own, by studying manuals, or learning the details in a training camp? We really do not know if the older brother attended a training camp yet, but I am projecting that he did in my comment.

    Like

  16. Gregory Avatar

    “I am suggesting that he was in a training camp.”
    I am suggesting we not make stuff up.
    My son, with Harvard and MIT ID’s, is among those hunkered down. With maybe a million people told to stay home, and 30 thousand man days in a typical lifetime, they’re blowing about 34 lifetimes a day, 1 1/2 lifetimes an hour, in the exercise. At some point very soon they should just let people go about their business.

    Like

  17. Ben Emery Avatar
    Ben Emery

    My tax day bomber narrative doesn’t seem likely at all and only time will tell what the motivations were for the two or more. Here is where I keep going in my head, the US has put Afghanistan and Iraqi population through this type of stuff as daily life for over a decade.
    Deadly wave of bombings across Iraq ahead of elections
    http://www.cnn.com/2013/04/15/world/meast/iraq-violence/index.html
    Red Cross: Security deteriorating in Afghanistan
    http://www.charlotteobserver.com/2013/04/17/3987716/officials-attacks-across-afghanistan.html

    Like

  18. George Rebane Avatar

    Gregory 1241pm – I am innocent (at least of that).
    Russ 1244pm – there are a lot of posted references that at least one brother received military training citing “as reported by NBC News”. But I have yet to find anything on a NBC site that confirms this.
    However, there are many citations quoting various sources (relatives, friends, etc) of the brothers’ strong religious feelings for Islam, and their difficulty in assimilating into American society.
    Speculation that they were Muslims did not require a stretch from probabilistic considerations. The media are avoiding connecting those dots like the plague.

    Like

  19. Todd Juvinall Avatar

    I see the blame America a first nuts are at it again. It is just like the USA in the wars over there they say. Cripes, the bodies are not warm yet and the little boy murdered here is not buried. I think those blamers are traitors.

    Like

  20. Gregory Avatar

    “My tax day bomber narrative doesn’t seem likely at all”
    “Doesn’t seem likely” is the funniest thing I’ve seen from you, Ben.
    No, a Moslem Chechen who prays towards Mecca five times a day (the older bomber) isn’t a likely Tea Party tax protester. Better luck next slaughter.

    Like

  21. George Rebane Avatar

    BenE 202pm – Thanks again for the perspective that all was honey and flowers in Iraq, Iran, Syria, Afghanistan, and Pakistan (throw in Chechnya, Libya, and some more ‘stans’ for good measure) before we Americans got there. I had forgotten how well they had it under Saddam, the Taliban, the mullahs, the Alawites, Mubarak, Gaddafi, … .

    Like

  22. Gregory Avatar

    George, I suspect the average Iraqi would choose the Baathists over the crap of the last decade, and I suspect we’d be better off had Ron Paul’s position in ’88 been more popular. It really wasn’t our business that Iraq invaded Kuwait in the first place, and we’d be better off had the Saudis had to clean up their own neighborhood. They’d still be fighting amongst themselves, the World Trade Center towers would still be standing and we’d already have the Keystone pipeline built and in commission 🙂
    Ben’s problem is one of misdirected moral equivalence; no, a couple of disaffected immigrants killing and maiming scores of innocents isn’t morally equivalent to the messy business of dealing with rogue governments that had killed and maimed, or helped those who killed and maimed, many hundreds of thousands of innocents. Someone needed to do it, just not us.

    Like

  23. Gregory Avatar

    The Boston area lockdown has ended as of a few minutes ago. One tv lip flapper reported there were 4 million people affected, which means about 6 lifetimes per hour were put on ice. Something like 50 lifetimes in total.
    Was it the right thing to do? Maybe, but we should have some concept as to the cost while doing it.

    Like

  24. Russ Steele Avatar

    In defense of my position that the oldest terrorist had some training. An expert on Russia at Fox News said that following his visit to Russia and to his father in Chechnya the older son started posting Jihad videos on his YouTube Channel and on his Russian version of Facebook. There are Jihadist training camps in Chechnya, and given his change in attitude, as reflected in the social media, it is reasonable to assume the training may of had some influence.
    The Russian Expert also pointed out that it takes some expertise and training to build suicide vests that work. It clear that one worked on Suspect #1 when he blew himself up. The pictures of the corpse shows a large hole on the body, like those made when explosives are attached to the body.
    Suspect #1 was flagged by a foreign government according to a FBI source, as a potential problem two years ago. He was on the FBI watch list, but escaped by not raising any level of concern.
    This is my case, what is the opposing case?

    Like

  25. Ben Emery Avatar
    Ben Emery

    George,
    Who said it was all honey? Why do we think as Americans we have the authority to dictate to the rest of the planet of how nation should be run? By example is the way to convert other nations to our form of government not by the size of the bombs or end of a barrel of gun.
    You need to ask yourself how and why did Saddam at any time have any kind of power, wmds, and the delivery system of those wmd’s?
    You need to ask yourself how did the Taliban come into being and gain control over Afghanistan?
    You need to ask yourself how did Osama bin Laden become a leader, power player, and enemy of the US?
    You need to ask yourself how and why are the OPEC nations or region so important for the US and developed nations?
    In the US over the last 80-100 years our foreign policies have created our “enemies”. I put the ” ” due to the fact they only became our enemies when they stopped being the puppets of the US.

    Like

  26. Michael Anderson Avatar
    Michael Anderson

    Gregory 100pm – David Brooks made that exact point on the News Hour tonight. He also took note that Israel, expert in how to deal with both professional and home-made terrorism, has long adopted a “business as usual” approach to these types of events–if a cafe is bombed the whole city rallies to make sure it is open the next day.
    And if you think about it, if the guy with the boat had walked his dog this morning instead of waiting for the “all clear,” he would have seen the blood on his driveway and on the hull some 10 hours sooner. Never underestimate the value of a motivated citizenry.
    Speaking of motivated citizenry, I think this is the best analysis I have read so far regarding the reasons why the faulty gun legislation did not pass:
    http://nyti.ms/YA1iyG

    Like

  27. Michael Anderson Avatar
    Michael Anderson

    GG wrote: “Better luck next slaughter,” which made me LOL, and then,
    “It really wasn’t our business that Iraq invaded Kuwait in the first place, and we’d be better off had the Saudis had to clean up their own neighborhood. They’d still be fighting amongst themselves, the World Trade Center towers would still be standing…”
    Totally agree. I’m even OK with the Keystone project as long as it’s done like Slow Food.
    Keach, you owe us a cookie.

    Like

  28. Russ Steele Avatar

    A former official with a state law-enforcement agency sent CalWatchDog a contrarian take on the week’s events in Massachusetts:
    “At the risk of spoiling the high fives on the Boston bombing incident, has anybody asked how this guy was not on the FBI’s radar 5 minutes after the terrorist attack.  He openly posted radical ideas and linked to Chechen terrorist videos on the internet and had just traveled back to the epicenter of terrorism, Chechnya and Dagestan?????   
    “We spend billions upon billions to gather intel, surveil the internet and identify potential threats.   JTTFs and terror centers and intel fusion hubs are to track and hopefully prevent these guys from acting.  At least he should have been on a short list of candidates within 12 hours of the bombing.  
    “Yet the FBI was reduced to posting blurry video photos like any 7-11 robbery 5 days after the attack.  really, only the amateur nature of the attackers led to their arrests…not brilliant police work.  Didn’t get any value from anti-terror money spent.  After 5 days it would seem like someone might have looked at the Chechens photographs, which the FBI presumably had, and a light bulb would have lit up. They lived in the neighborhood!  The leader was a wife-beater!

    Read the rest HERE: http://www.calwatchdog.com/2013/04/20/ex-ca-cop-u-s-law-enforcement-blew-terror-response/

    Like

  29. Gregory Avatar

    Russ, 1:06
    The movie quote that comes to mind is…
    “Round up the usual suspects”
    -Captain Renault, “Casablanca”

    Like

Leave a comment