Rebane's Ruminations
February 2011
S M T W T F S
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728  

ARCHIVES


OUR LINKS


YubaNet
White House Blog
Watts Up With That?
The Union
Sierra Thread
RL “Bob” Crabb
Barry Pruett Blog

George Rebane

Unionists in Wisconsin and their sympathy demonstrators across the country have been taught new slogans to shout.  These are various forms of ‘violating workers’ rights’, and that cutting back the power of public employees unions is ‘an attack on America’s middle class’.  Both are false, but both are powerful since most listeners don’t have the equipment to parse the lies.

The notion of ‘right’ has long since lost its useful meaning in public discourse.  Nobody knows what the other means when they use the word.  (More on Rights & Privileges)  The Federal Government, by law, and the Wisconsin government, by law, have given their public employee unions certain rights to negotiate wages and benefits.  What is given by law, can be taken away by law – all the way up to the Constitution.

Were the Wisconsin government gratuitously to refuse to negotiate with the unions under present law, then the unions and their bussed in demonstrators could argue that their rights were being violated without first being rescinded by due process.  But that clearly is not the case, as the 14 Democratic legislators hiding out in Chicago can attest.

The ‘attack on the middle class’ shout is not only a blatant lie, it’s 180 degrees out from reality.  It is the middle class that has to bear the tax burden which union fat cats – both leaders and members – enjoy in their outrageous compensation packages that are breaking the fiscal backs of the states.  If anything, what Wisconsin and other states are attempting with their public service unions is to rescue the middle class, and save these non-union workers from the union onslaught that has been going on for years and must finally be brought to a halt.

Posted in , ,

8 responses to “Workers’ Rights and Attack on the Middle Class”

  1. Mikey McD Avatar

    The best definition/summary of “rights” ever recorded to paper. http://www.aynrand.org/site/PageServer?pagename=arc_ayn_rand_man_rights

    Like

  2. George Rebane Avatar

    Rand’s “best definition” is an apology for a basis for rights that hangs on a specific moral code – a fluid set of correct responses to life’s situations which is culture specific and therefore not absolute.
    An existential right is one that is granted and guaranteed by a power that can enforce the individual’s exercise of said right. It is independent of whether such a permission is moral or not. Rand’s moral rights are a subset of the operational definition of rights, and applies only if the granting power has the wherewithal and will to enforce them. Else it is just words that express a wished for ideal.
    With respect for the many things for which I admire Rand, I cannot accept her weak definition of right as an absolute based on only one moral code, and that needs to be enforced by no one.

    Like

  3. Todd Juvinall Avatar
    Todd Juvinall

    Who sang, “The Times they are a changin”? Was that Dylan?

    Like

  4. Dixon Cruickshank Avatar
    Dixon Cruickshank

    ya
    right on target

    Like

  5. Dixon Cruickshank Avatar
    Dixon Cruickshank

    This just dawned on me, since many of the worest states were controlled by the union/democratic relationship of back scratching, this really could be considered a somewhat revelution against the Gov itself – as they became one in the same.

    Like

  6. George Rebane Avatar

    Point well made Dixon. Robert Barro of Harvard and the Hoover Institute makes the point “Collective bargaining on a broad scale is more similar to an antitrust violation than to a civil liberty.” And that violation is actually a collusion between government and unions to bilk the taxpayer.
    http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704409004576146061231899264.html?mod=WSJ_hp_LEFTTopStories

    Like

  7. Dixon Cruickshank Avatar
    Dixon Cruickshank

    I read that too, it is kinda like taxation without representation – I heard that someplace, just can’t remember………
    82+ today George but a cold front is due tomorrow going to knock it down all the way to 78 again – just say’in
    After the coldest Dec. on record this must be the warmest Feb on record, unbelieveably nice, Feb is usually pretty nasty

    Like

  8. Dixon Cruickshank Avatar
    Dixon Cruickshank

    And Obama wants us to be part of the new Global Governence – wonderful insight:
    Just when Libya, a member of the United Nations’ Human Rights Council, is machine-gunning its citizens….
    (The) Human Rights Council is poised to adopt a report chock-full of praise for Libya’s human rights record.
    The review commends Libya for improving educational opportunities, for making human rights a “priority” and for bettering its “constitutional” framework. Several countries, including Iran, Venezuela, North Korea, and Saudi Arabia but also Canada, give Libya positive marks for the legal protections afforded to its citizens—who are now revolting against the regime and facing bloody reprisal. …

    Like

Leave a comment