Rebane's Ruminations
March 2009
S M T W T F S
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293031  

ARCHIVES


OUR LINKS


YubaNet
White House Blog
Watts Up With That?
The Union
Sierra Thread
RL “Bob” Crabb
Barry Pruett Blog

George Rebane

NCeconForecast09 Nevada County’s economic prospects were the subject of a 200 person gathering this morning at the GV Holiday Inn Express.  Always interested in things economic and financial, Jo Ann and I were there munching breakfast with the movers and shakers of our community – I think we were allowed in on a forged hall pass.  This year’s Nevada County Economic Forecast was a worthwhile event that was hosted by Gil Mathew, President/CEO Nevada County ERC, and Judy Hess, President/CEO Citizens Bank of Northern CA.  The featured speakers were Mr. Gary Zimmerman, Senior Economist, Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, and Dr. David Gallo, Professor of Economics, Cal State Chico.

Gary Zimmerman took us through a detailed examination of the current financial crisis with a basket full of charts and graphs.  We all learned what the recent trail of tears looked like in terms of unemployment, lending, foreclosures, GDP, ‘monetary easing’ (aka printing money), and so on.  GaryZ is a knowledgeable and entertaining speaker, and not an economist who takes himself too seriously.  My takeaway from his talk was a better understanding of how independent the Fed seems to be from the Obama administration and Congress viz their current plans to fix the economy.  No one seems to know or even really care if they can take the ongoing and proposed nostrums coming out of Washington, and somehow map them into what effect it will have on the country’s longer term GDP.  To me at least, it seems important whether our 2019 national debt is going to be the Obama predicted $22T, or something like $33T, or even $44T.  Today the country appears numb to all such numbers and concerns.

After the break David Gallo, another well-educated humorist in his own right, took the podium and gave us surprisingly good news about Nevada County.  DavidG runs the Center for Economic Development at Chico and is the recognized maven for things economic in northern California.  I’ll blow the punch line right away – Nevada County is not doing all that badly compared to what’s happening in California and the nation.  In fact, compared to the mess next door in Sacramento County, we’re soaring economically.  He presented a lot of numbers to back up his assessments, and promised to let GilM have a copy of the PowerPoint so that it can be posted on the ERC site (to which RR will link).  I think his most important message for Nevada County was that “we’re at the bottom” of the real estate market now, and that our “economic base has not been damaged” in any real sense by this recession.

The last event of the session was a stand-up comic who should have remained sitting down.

When the crowd dispersed, GilM invited me to meet with him, Judy Hess, and the two speakers.  In the following hour we went over the main results of the presentations, dug deeper into the quality of the input data, and reviewed the analytics behind the Fed’s assessment of the economy and the CED’s ongoing monitoring of northern California county economies.  (As a systems scientist I was particularly interested in how little technology transfer has taken place from my field to the area of economics.) Much of our discussion related to the work that SESF and the Sierra Economic Development District are doing with ERC in how to measure the state of Nevada County’s economy.  We were happy to get some references to similar work ongoing in other northern California counties, and to involve these economists in reviewing our progress in the out-months.  All in all, it was a productive meeting and an informative morning.  Kudos to GilM and JudyH for putting on this event.

[28mar09 update]  Dr. David Gallo just emailed me the pdf of his excellent PowerPoint presentation on the 2009 Nevada County economic forecast.  Now you can delve into the details of the CED analysis. You can download the 2MB file here Download Nevada County Economic Forecast 2009.

[9apr09 update] Mr. Gary Zimmerman, Senior Economist at the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, was kind enough to send me the complete and updated edition of the PowerPoint presentation that he presented at the posted meeting.  As promised, the 1.24MB file can be downloaded here Download Zimmerman 2009-3-25 Grass Valley Conf – PRES Final 2.

Posted in , ,

6 responses to “Nevada County Economic Forecast – 2009 (9apr09 update)”

  1. Russ Steele Avatar

    George,
    Thanks for the good report. I was disappointed that Ellen and I could not join you, as the past Economic Forecast presentations have been most insightful. I look forward to more details over some coffee or a glass of wine.
    The book research at the UC Berkeley Library has produced some very positive results, though it is going slower than I expected. We will be planning another trip to Berkeley in May. The Cobalt book proof looks fantastic! Final review tomorrow and it goes to press next week.

    Like

  2. Aaron Avatar

    George, thanks for the great review of the meeting. Wish I could have been there, but I feel like I have been now. 🙂

    Like

  3. Scott Obermuller Avatar

    Thanks for the virtual attendance, George. This county has always done better than most through the last 100 years, but I wonder if that trend will carry us through the problems we are facing. Even before the current mess that has blown up, we were facing a coming crunch of unfunded obligations that was never fully addressed. To a certain extent, that has now melded into the larger financial problem that we face, but a lot has been ignored or shoved under the rug. Much economic activity locally came from retired, or relocating folks that cashed out of their homes in the bay area or southern Cal and brought their new-found wealth to our great climate and view. How much of that will continue? Tourism did well, but the “green” mania of discouraging energy use will/is hurting that segment. We are tied, like it or not, to a state government that is increasingly socialist/incompetent and that has many ramifications in how expensive it is to live/build/work anywhere in this county. Our own good citizens are increasingly intolerant of anything involving resource extraction, or large scale manufacturing. The quaint notion of encouraging lots of high value “clean” high tech cottage industries does not stand up to the real and varied needs of a viable community. We relied on that single-crop source of employment for a while and it is now withering. I could go on and on, but the main point here is that we did well locally mostly because of capitalism and individual initiative and bottom up growth. That is not the coming thing. Money will flow from a printing press directed by the govt and I can’t see how they will direct it towards a county populated by the very type of citizen that is regarded as the cause of our economic mess. On top of that is the coming boat load of measures to actively restrict/discourage rural growth. “Smart growth” and all of that. Paying a 50% premium to have my front window view be that of some other persons front window 10 feet away won’t be an attractive option to a lot of folks who value country living. The bottom line is that I always thought that I’d be happy to live out my days here, but that idea is being rapidly modified by the things I see coming. I’m not alone. The money/brain drain is already in full motion out of California and possibly (sadly) our nation as well. We always have mass and inertia to consider in any equation and this county still has a lot of what made it good in the first place. How long it will continue to be good here is the $64K question, and we will all come up with our own individual answer.
    God Bless

    Like

  4. patrick tobin Avatar
    patrick tobin

    Good report George, I learned a few things,
    Patrick Tobin

    Like

  5. Russ Steele Avatar

    George,
    I looked trough the Power Point Presentation by Dr. David Gallo and it sounds too rosy for me. CARB continues to implement their Scoping Plan for greenhouse gas reduction, with the adoption of early action regulations by 2010. Sept 2010, when the economy is about to turn around, CARB will adopt the final GHG targets for the 18 regions of the state. The Spring of 2011 is the deadline for updating the regional transportation plan to addresses how to reduce GHG from private auto travel, 76% of the total. CARB’s goal by 2050 is to reduce the average daily miles traveled by households by 12 miles. This will make Nevada County housing more expensive for commuters and could restrict the flow of tourist to Nevada City and Grass Valley, and even Truckee. “Sorry, Johnny, we can not go to Nevada County this weekend, we have exceed our carbon credits for the week. Those two trips to the dentist for your tooth, blew out our carbon credit allotment.”
    Did Dr. Gallo make any mention of these regulatory constraints? They will certainly have an economic impact on California. The experience in Spain was that alternative energy sources doubled the cost. I cannot see how doubling the cost of energy for business and households will cannot have an impact on transportation and tourism. Families will not be taking fun trips, when they do not have enough gas money to buy gas for the commute to work, or to keep the house warm in winter and cool in summer.
    One thing that Nevada County could do to help the housing market recover would be to review all the zoning and planning regulations to remove any development hurdles, or at least lower the hurdles.

    Like

  6. George Rebane Avatar
    George Rebane

    Excellent points Russ. Neither my notes nor recollections have any mention of the effect that the California Carbon Catastrophe (aka AB32) will have on the economy. And I agree, igoring its effect in any economic projection will compromise it from the start.

    Like

Leave a comment